Department of Psychology, University of North Texas, Denton, TX, United States.
Department of Psychology, University of North Texas, Denton, TX, United States.
J Neurosci Methods. 2017 Nov 1;291:13-19. doi: 10.1016/j.jneumeth.2017.07.027. Epub 2017 Aug 3.
Virtual reality-based neuropsychological assessments proffer the potential to address the limited ecological validity of pen-and-paper measures of memory.
To investigate the construct validity of a newly developed virtual reality-based multiple errands task, the Virtual Environment Grocery Store (VEGS), two studies were performed.
COMPARISON WITH EXISTING METHOD(S): In Study 1, we explored construct validity via comparison of traditional neuropsychological measures of memory and executive functioning with a low distraction condition of the VEGS. In Study 2, a new sample was used to compare traditional neuropsychological measures of memory and executive functioning with a high distraction condition of the VEGS.
Performances on the VEGS memory tasks (in Study 1: low distraction condition) and the traditional neuropsychological assessments of memory were positively correlated, indicating that memory for VEGS content was similar to memory for traditional paper-and-pencil measures. Again, in Study 2, performances on the VEGS memory tasks correlated with the traditional neuropsychological assessments of memory, indicating that memory for VEGS content was similar to memory for traditional paper-and-pencil measures. As expected, though, the addition of distractors into the virtual environment resulted in significant correlations with traditional measures of inhibitory control.
The VEGS has the advantage over traditional measures of providing objective measurement of individual components of memory in simulations of everyday activities.
基于虚拟现实的神经心理学评估提供了一种潜在的方法,可以解决纸笔记忆测试中生态有效性有限的问题。
为了研究新开发的基于虚拟现实的多项任务(虚拟环境杂货店,VEGS)的结构有效性,进行了两项研究。
在研究 1 中,我们通过比较传统的记忆和执行功能神经心理学测试与 VEGS 的低干扰条件,探讨了结构有效性。在研究 2 中,使用新的样本将传统的记忆和执行功能神经心理学测试与 VEGS 的高干扰条件进行比较。
在 VEGS 记忆任务(研究 1:低干扰条件)和传统的纸笔记忆测试中的表现呈正相关,表明对 VEGS 内容的记忆与对传统纸笔测试的记忆相似。同样,在研究 2 中,VEGS 记忆任务的表现与传统的记忆神经心理学测试呈正相关,表明对 VEGS 内容的记忆与对传统纸笔测试的记忆相似。不过,正如预期的那样,在虚拟环境中增加干扰因素与传统的抑制控制测试呈显著相关。
与传统的测试相比,VEGS 具有提供日常活动模拟中记忆的个体成分的客观测量的优势。