Paller Channing J, Cole Alexander P, Partin Alan W, Carducci Michael A, Kanarek Norma F
Sidney Kimmel Comprehensive Cancer Center, Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, Baltimore, Maryland.
Center for Surgery and Public Health, Division of Urological Surgery, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts.
Prostate. 2017 May;77(13):1366-1372. doi: 10.1002/pros.23396. Epub 2017 Aug 8.
Root cause analysis is a technique used to assess systems factors related to "sentinel events"-serious adverse events within healthcare systems. This technique is commonly used to identify factors, which allowed these adverse events to occur, to target areas for improvement and to improve health care delivery systems. We sought to apply this technique to men presenting with metastatic prostate cancer (PCa).
We performed an in-depth case series analysis of 15 patients, who presented with metastatic disease at Johns Hopkins Sidney Kimmel Comprehensive Cancer Center using root cause analysis to refine a list of health system factors that lead to late stage presentation in the current era.
Key factors in late diagnosis of PCa included lack of insurance, lack of routine PSA testing, comorbidities, reticence of patients to follow up actionable PSA, and aggressive disease. Three patients had aggressive disease that would not have been discovered at an early stage in the disease process, despite routine screening. However, analysis of the remaining 12 patients illuminated health system factors led to missing important diagnostic information, which might have led to diagnosis of PCa at a curable stage.
The cases help highlight the need for systems based approaches to early diagnosis of PCa. A heterogeneous group of barriers to early diagnosis were identified in our series of patients including economic, health systems, and cultural factors. These findings underscore the need for individualized approaches to preventing delayed diagnosis of PCa. While limited by our single-institution scope, this approach provides a model for research and quality improvement initiatives to identify modifiable systems factors impeding appropriate diagnoses of PCa.
根本原因分析是一种用于评估与“警讯事件”(医疗系统内的严重不良事件)相关的系统因素的技术。该技术通常用于识别导致这些不良事件发生的因素,确定需要改进的领域,并改善医疗服务提供系统。我们试图将此技术应用于转移性前列腺癌(PCa)患者。
我们对15例在约翰霍普金斯西德尼·金梅尔综合癌症中心被诊断为转移性疾病的患者进行了深入的病例系列分析,采用根本原因分析来完善导致当前时代晚期就诊的卫生系统因素清单。
前列腺癌晚期诊断的关键因素包括缺乏保险、缺乏常规PSA检测、合并症、患者不愿对可采取行动的PSA结果进行随访以及侵袭性疾病。3例患者患有侵袭性疾病,即使进行常规筛查,在疾病早期也无法发现。然而,对其余12例患者的分析表明,卫生系统因素导致遗漏了重要诊断信息,而这些信息可能会在可治愈阶段诊断出前列腺癌。
这些病例有助于凸显基于系统方法进行前列腺癌早期诊断的必要性。在我们的患者系列中,发现了一系列导致早期诊断的异质性障碍,包括经济、卫生系统和文化因素。这些发现强调了采取个性化方法预防前列腺癌延迟诊断的必要性。虽然受限于我们单机构的范围,但这种方法为研究和质量改进计划提供了一个模型,以识别阻碍前列腺癌正确诊断的可改变系统因素。