Cornelissen Dennis, Mwapasa Gerald, Gajewski Jakub, McCauley Tracey, Borgstein Eric, Brugha Ruairi, Bijlmakers Leon
Radboud University Medical Centre Netherlands, Geert Grooteplein Zuid 10, 6525 GA, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
College of Medicine, University of Malawi, Mahatma Gandhi, Blantyre, Malawi.
World J Surg. 2018 Jan;42(1):46-53. doi: 10.1007/s00268-017-4166-5.
Three district hospitals in Malawi that provide essential surgery, which for many patients can be lifesaving or prevent disability, formed the setting of this costing study.
All resources used at district hospitals for the delivery of surgery were identified and quantified. The hospital departments were divided into three categories of cost centres-the final cost centre, intermediate and ancillary cost centres. All costs of human resources, buildings, equipment, medical and non-medical supplies and utilities were quantified and allocated to surgery through step-down accounting.
The total cost of surgery, including post-operative care, ranged from US$ 329,000 per year to more than twice that amount at one of the hospitals. At two hospitals, it represented 16-17% of the total cost of running the hospital. The main cost drivers of surgery were transport and inpatient services, including catering. The cost of a C-section ranged from $ 164 to 638 that of a hernia repair from $ 137 to 598. Evacuations from uterus were cheapest mainly because of the shorter duration of patient stay.
Low bed occupancy rates and utilisation rates of the operating theatres suggest overcapacity but may also indicate a potential to scale up surgery. This may be achieved by adding surgical staff, although there may be rate-limiting steps, such as demand for surgery in the community or capacity to provide anaesthesia. If a scale-up of surgery cannot be realised, hospital managers may be forced to reduce the number of beds, reorganise wards and/or reallocate staff to achieve better economies of scale.
马拉维的三家地区医院提供基本外科手术,对许多患者来说,这种手术可能挽救生命或预防残疾,这构成了本成本研究的背景。
确定并量化了地区医院开展手术所使用的所有资源。医院科室被分为三类成本中心——最终成本中心、中间成本中心和辅助成本中心。通过逐步递减核算,对人力资源、建筑、设备、医疗和非医疗用品以及公用事业的所有成本进行了量化,并分配到外科手术中。
包括术后护理在内的手术总成本每年从32.9万美元到其中一家医院超过该金额两倍不等。在两家医院,这占医院运营总成本的16 - 17%。手术的主要成本驱动因素是交通和住院服务,包括餐饮。剖宫产的成本从164美元到638美元不等,疝气修补的成本从137美元到598美元不等。子宫排空手术最便宜,主要是因为患者住院时间较短。
低床位占用率和手术室利用率表明存在产能过剩,但也可能表明有扩大手术规模的潜力。这可以通过增加外科工作人员来实现,尽管可能存在一些限制因素,如社区对手术的需求或提供麻醉的能力。如果无法实现手术规模的扩大,医院管理者可能被迫减少床位数量、重组病房和/或重新分配工作人员以实现更好的规模经济。