Wolff J, Nonnemann H C
Aktuelle Traumatol. 1986 Oct;16(5):196-202.
There is no doubt that primary suturing of the ruptured ankle ligament gives the best results regarding joint stability. However, there are differing views concerning the follow-up treatment. In particular, there are controversial opinions about the value of a special shoe by Dr. Spring during the rehabilitation phase. During the period April 1984 to July 1985 100 patients with rupture of the fibular ligament were treated operatively, 50 of whom were treated post-operatively with 14-day lying plaster of Paris followed by a further 14 days with the special shoe from Dr. Spring and 50 with a lower leg walking plaster of Paris. The results were compared over a period of 8 weeks, using objective criteria. The subjective impressions followed after at least 6 months. After 8 weeks the mobility of the joint in dorsalflexion and pronation is similar in both groups; in plantar flexion and supination better mobility was seen after the plaster of Paris treatment. There was no significant difference in the duration of unfitness for work. Subjectively, there was a reduced tendency to swelling after the plaster of Paris treatment.
毫无疑问,就关节稳定性而言,对断裂的踝关节韧带进行一期缝合可获得最佳效果。然而,关于后续治疗存在不同观点。特别是,对于斯普林博士发明的一种特殊鞋子在康复阶段的价值存在争议性意见。在1984年4月至1985年7月期间,对100例腓侧韧带断裂患者进行了手术治疗,其中50例术后先用14天的巴黎石膏固定,随后再使用斯普林博士发明的特殊鞋子14天,另外50例则使用小腿行走巴黎石膏。使用客观标准在8周的时间内对结果进行了比较。主观印象至少在6个月后得出。8周后,两组关节背屈和内旋的活动度相似;跖屈和外旋在使用巴黎石膏治疗后活动度更好。在无法工作的持续时间上没有显著差异。主观上,使用巴黎石膏治疗后肿胀的倾向有所减轻。