Boucher M, Duchêne-Marullaz P, Moundanga J L
Br J Pharmacol. 1986 Sep;89(1):119-27. doi: 10.1111/j.1476-5381.1986.tb11127.x.
Atrial and ventricular chronotropic effects of the individual stereoisomers of propranolol, pindolol, metoprolol and penbutolol were studied in conscious dogs with chronic atrio-ventricular (A-V) block. Ventricular beta-adrenoceptor blocking activity was assessed for all drugs against isoprenaline under the same experimental conditions. At low doses, the stereoisomers of propranolol and penbutolol decreased atrial rate, whereas those of pindolol and metoprolol produced an increase. At higher doses, all drugs increased atrial rate. All drugs decreased ventricular rate dose-dependently except (+)-pindolol. Relative ventricular beta-blocking potencies of the (-)-isomers of propranolol, pindolol, metoprolol and penbutolol were respectively 38, 21, greater than 43 and 31 times higher than those of their corresponding (+)-isomers. In addition, beta-blocking potencies of (-)- and (+)-pindolol were respectively 60 and 120 times higher, those of (-)- and (+)-penbutolol 7 and 8 times higher and those of (-)- and (+)-metoprolol 4 and greater than 4 times weaker than those of (-)- and (+)-propranolol. At comparable levels of ventricular beta-adrenoceptor blockade, (-)-pindolol and (-)-metoprolol were more potent in producing ventricular bradycardia than their respective (+)-isomers, whereas (-)- and (+)-propranolol and (-)- and (+)-penbutolol were equiactive. In addition, regardless of which isomer was being studied, the order of ventricular bradycardiac potencies, at comparable levels of beta-adrenoceptor blockade, was metoprolol greater than propranolol greater than penbutolol greater than pindolol. In addition, regardless of which isomer was being studied, the order of ventricular bradycardiac potencies, at comparable levels of beta-adrenoceptor blockade, was metoprolol > propranolol > penbutolol >pindolol. 5 These results show that antagonism of beta-adrenoceptors in the ventricle is at least partly responsible for the ventricular bradycardiac effect produced by these drugs, but also that some other factor, apparently distinct from the membrane stabilizing activity, is involved, suggesting the existence of some other as yet unknown pharmacological property of the beta-adrenoceptor blocking drugs, especially evident in metoprolol. Finally, these results demonstrate that the intrinsic sympathomimetic activity exhibited by some of these drugs attenuate their bradycardiac effect.
在患有慢性房室(A-V)传导阻滞的清醒犬中,研究了普萘洛尔、吲哚洛尔、美托洛尔和喷布洛尔各自立体异构体的心房和心室变时作用。在相同实验条件下,针对所有药物,以异丙肾上腺素为对照评估心室β-肾上腺素受体阻断活性。低剂量时,普萘洛尔和喷布洛尔的立体异构体降低心房率,而吲哚洛尔和美托洛尔的立体异构体则使其升高。高剂量时,所有药物均使心房率升高。除(+)-吲哚洛尔外,所有药物均剂量依赖性地降低心室率。普萘洛尔、吲哚洛尔、美托洛尔和喷布洛尔的(-)-异构体的相对心室β-阻断效能分别比其相应的(+)-异构体高38、21、大于43和31倍。此外,(-)-和(+)-吲哚洛尔的β-阻断效能分别比(-)-和(+)-普萘洛尔高60和120倍,(-)-和(+)-喷布洛尔高7和8倍,(-)-和(+)-美托洛尔比(-)-和(+)-普萘洛尔弱4倍和大于4倍。在心室β-肾上腺素受体阻断水平相当的情况下,(-)-吲哚洛尔和(-)-美托洛尔比各自的(+)-异构体更有效地产生心室心动过缓,而(-)-和(+)-普萘洛尔以及(-)-和(+)-喷布洛尔具有同等活性。此外,无论研究哪种异构体,在β-肾上腺素受体阻断水平相当的情况下,心室心动过缓效能的顺序为美托洛尔>普萘洛尔>喷布洛尔>吲哚洛尔。这些结果表明,心室中β-肾上腺素受体的拮抗作用至少部分是这些药物产生心室心动过缓效应的原因,但也表明存在一些其他因素,显然与膜稳定活性不同,这提示β-肾上腺素受体阻断药物存在一些其他未知的药理学特性,在美托洛尔中尤为明显。最后,这些结果表明,其中一些药物表现出的内在拟交感活性减弱了它们的心动过缓效应。