Robb Gillian, Loe Elizabeth, Maharaj Ashika, Hamblin Richard, Seddon Mary E
Senior Advisor, Health Quality & Safety Commission, Wellington, Professional Teaching Fellow, University of Auckland.
Medication Safety Specialist, Health Quality & Safety Commission, Wellington.
N Z Med J. 2017 Aug 11;130(1460):21-32.
The purpose of this study is to identify patterns of medication-related harm from a national perspective, and to use this information to inform decisions on where to focus medication safety efforts. This study updates a 2013 study using the same methodology.
District health boards (DHBs) still actively using either the Adverse Drug Event (ADE) Trigger Tool (TT) or the Global Trigger Tool (GTT), submitted two years of anonymised ADE data (1 July 2013-30 June 2015) to the Health Quality & Safety Commission (the Commission) using a standard template. Analyses were conducted using aggregated data only.
Of eight DHBs who submitted data, six datasets were included, representing a total of 2,659 chart reviews. From these reviews, 923 harms were identified in 751 patients, with 28% of patients experiencing one or more harms. Harms occurred at a rate of 34.7 per 100 admissions, 42.5 per 1,000 bed days and 28% of patients experienced one or more medication-related harms. Those harmed were more likely to be older, female and have an increased length of stay. Most harms (65%) occurred during an inpatient stay, however, a substantial number (29%) originated in the community and precipitated an admission. Across all levels of severity, the most common types of medication harm were constipation, hypotension and bleeding. In the more serious harm categories, bleeding, hypotension and delirium/confusion/over-sedation were most common. Six groups of medicines caused the greatest amount of harm: opioids (including tramadol), anticoagulants/antiplatelet agents, antibiotics, antianginals (beta-blockers, nitrates, calcium channel blockers and others), diuretics and other cardiovascular medicines (angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors, angiotensin II receptor antagonists (ARBs), centrally acting agents and statins). Opioids and anticoagulants/antiplatelet agents not only accounted for 40% of all harm, they were implicated in the most severe harm.
This paper confirms earlier work that medication-related harms are common, occur both in hospitals and in the community, and are a substantial burden for patients and our healthcare system. Work is underway at local and national levels to decrease this harm, with a focus on the high-risk medicines most commonly implicated.
本研究旨在从全国角度识别与药物相关的伤害模式,并利用这些信息为药物安全工作的重点决策提供依据。本研究采用相同方法更新了2013年的一项研究。
仍在积极使用药物不良事件(ADE)触发工具(TT)或全球触发工具(GTT)的地区卫生委员会(DHBs),使用标准模板向卫生质量与安全委员会(委员会)提交了两年的匿名ADE数据(2013年7月1日至2015年6月30日)。仅使用汇总数据进行分析。
在提交数据的8个DHBs中,纳入了6个数据集,代表总共2659次病历审查。从这些审查中,在751名患者中识别出923起伤害事件,28%的患者经历了一种或多种伤害。伤害发生率为每100例入院患者34.7起、每1000个住院日42.5起,28%的患者经历了一种或多种与药物相关的伤害。受伤害的患者更可能是老年人、女性,且住院时间更长。大多数伤害(65%)发生在住院期间,然而,相当数量(29%)起源于社区并导致入院。在所有严重程度级别中,最常见的药物伤害类型是便秘、低血压和出血。在更严重的伤害类别中,出血、低血压和谵妄/意识模糊/过度镇静最为常见。六类药物造成的伤害最大:阿片类药物(包括曲马多)、抗凝剂/抗血小板药物、抗生素、抗心绞痛药物(β受体阻滞剂、硝酸盐、钙通道阻滞剂等)、利尿剂和其他心血管药物(血管紧张素转换酶(ACE)抑制剂、血管紧张素II受体拮抗剂(ARBs)、中枢作用药物和他汀类药物)。阿片类药物和抗凝剂/抗血小板药物不仅占所有伤害的40%,还与最严重的伤害有关。
本文证实了早期的研究结果,即与药物相关的伤害很常见,在医院和社区都会发生,对患者和我们的医疗系统来说是一项沉重负担。地方和国家层面正在开展工作以减少这种伤害,重点关注最常涉及的高风险药物。