Charles E. Schmidt College of Medicine, Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton.
Christine E. Lynn College of Nursing, Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton.
Am J Med. 2017 Nov;130(11):e487-e489. doi: 10.1016/j.amjmed.2017.07.019. Epub 2017 Aug 7.
On a daily basis, healthcare providers, especially those dealing with terminally ill patients, such as hospice workers, witness how advance directives help ensure the wishes of patients. They also witness the deleterious consequences when patients fail to document the care they desire at their end of life. To the best of our knowledge there are no data concerning the prevalence of advance directives among hospice healthcare providers. We therefore explored the prevalence and factors influencing completion rates in a survey of hospice healthcare providers.
Surveys that included 32 items to explore completion rates, as well as barriers, knowledge, and demographics, were e-mailed to 2097 healthcare providers, including employees and volunteers, at a nonprofit hospice.
Of 890 respondents, 44% reported having completed an advance directive. Ethnicity, age, relationship status, and perceived knowledge were all significant factors influencing the completion rates, whereas years of experience or working directly with patients had no effect. Procrastination, fear of the subject, and costs were common reasons reported as barriers. Upon completion of the survey, 43% said they will now complete an advance directive, and 45% will talk to patients and families about their wishes.
The majority of hospice healthcare providers have not completed an advance directive. These results are very similar to those for other healthcare providers treating patients with terminal diseases, specifically oncologists. Because, at completion, 43% said that they would now complete an advance directive, such a survey of healthcare providers may help increase completion rates.
在日常生活中,医疗保健提供者,特别是那些处理绝症患者的医疗保健提供者,如临终关怀工作者,见证了预先指示如何帮助确保患者的意愿得到实现。他们也见证了当患者未能在生命末期记录他们所期望的护理时产生的有害后果。据我们所知,没有关于临终关怀医疗保健提供者中预先指示的流行率的数据。因此,我们在对临终关怀医疗保健提供者的调查中探讨了预先指示的流行率和影响完成率的因素。
包括 32 个项目的调查问卷,旨在探索完成率以及障碍、知识和人口统计学,通过电子邮件发送给一家非营利性临终关怀机构的 2097 名医疗保健提供者,包括员工和志愿者。
在 890 名受访者中,44%的人报告已经完成了预先指示。种族、年龄、婚姻状况和感知知识都是影响完成率的重要因素,而工作经验或与患者直接接触则没有影响。拖延、对该主题的恐惧和成本是常见的被报告的障碍原因。在完成调查后,43%的人表示他们现在将完成一份预先指示,45%的人将与患者和家属讨论他们的意愿。
大多数临终关怀医疗保健提供者尚未完成预先指示。这些结果与治疗终末期疾病患者的其他医疗保健提供者,特别是肿瘤学家的结果非常相似。由于在完成调查后,有 43%的人表示他们现在将完成一份预先指示,因此对医疗保健提供者进行这样的调查可能有助于提高完成率。