Dept. of Radiology, Helsinki University Hospital and University of Helsinki, Haartmaninkatu 4, HUS 00029, POB 340, Helsinki, Finland.
Dept. of Radiology, East Tallinn Central Hospital, Ravi tn.18, 10138, Tallinn, Estonia.
Clin Neuroradiol. 2018 Dec;28(4):523-528. doi: 10.1007/s00062-017-0617-5. Epub 2017 Aug 11.
To assess the usefulness of the new computed tomography (CT) classification criteria proposed by Horowitz et al. and their effect on inter-observer agreement when estimating intracranial complications of acute mastoiditis.
In this study 53 contrast-enhanced CT scans of patients with acute mastoiditis were each retrospectively reviewed by two radiologists, using two different assessment criteria for intracranial complications. According to the new criteria, intracranial CT findings in the perisinuous area were graded into four classes (I normal, II linear halo, III nodular halo ≤4 mm thick and IV nodular halo >4 mm thick), where classes III and IV indicate a high risk for epidural abscesses. Inter-reader agreement was estimated by weighted kappa analysis for both methods.
With the old method, epidural abscesses were suspected in six and venous sinus thrombosis in five patients. With the new method, high-risk perisinuous lesions (classes III or IV) were detected in 11 patients, and sinus thrombosis outside the perisinuous area in 3 patients. All epidural abscesses were in the perisinuous area. Of the patients four, in whom intracranial pathology was not suspected with the old method, fell into the high-risk group (class III) according to the new method. All class IV lesions were also determined to be pathological with the old method. The inter-observer agreement (weighted kappa) rose from 0.21 (old method) to 0.80 (new method) when assessing epidural abscesses and from 0.44 (old method) to 0.85 (new method) when assessing sinus thrombosis.
The new assessment method raised the inter-observer agreement for detection of intracranial acute mastoiditis complications, namely epidural abscesses and venous sinus thrombosis.
评估 Horowitz 等人提出的新计算机断层扫描 (CT) 分类标准的实用性,以及其对评估急性乳突炎颅内并发症时观察者间一致性的影响。
本研究回顾性分析了 53 例急性乳突炎患者的增强 CT 扫描,由两名放射科医生使用两种不同的颅内并发症评估标准进行评估。根据新的标准,将沿岩骨区的颅内 CT 表现分为 4 级(I 级正常,II 级线状晕环,III 级结节状晕环厚度≤4mm,IV 级结节状晕环厚度>4mm),其中 III 级和 IV 级提示硬膜外脓肿的风险较高。两种方法的读者间一致性均采用加权 Kappa 分析进行评估。
采用旧方法,怀疑有 6 例硬膜外脓肿和 5 例静脉窦血栓形成。采用新方法,11 例患者存在高危沿岩骨区病变(III 级或 IV 级),3 例患者存在窦外静脉窦血栓形成。所有硬膜外脓肿均位于沿岩骨区。在旧方法中,4 例患者未怀疑颅内病变,但根据新方法,他们被归入高危组(III 级)。所有 IV 级病变在旧方法中也被确定为病理性。评估硬膜外脓肿和评估静脉窦血栓形成时,观察者间一致性(加权 Kappa)分别从旧方法的 0.21 提高到 0.80 和从 0.44 提高到 0.85。
新的评估方法提高了对颅内急性乳突炎并发症(即硬膜外脓肿和静脉窦血栓形成)的观察者间一致性。