Seidman H, Selikoff I J, Gelb S K
Am J Ind Med. 1986;10(5-6):479-514. doi: 10.1002/ajim.4700100506.
A cohort of 820 men in a Paterson, New Jersey, amosite asbestos factory which began work during 1941-1945 was observed from 5 to 40 years after start of work. Most of the cohort had limited duration of work experience (days, weeks, months), though some men worked for several years until the factory closed in 1954. With white males of New Jersey as the control population, Standardized Mortality Ratios (SMRs) of 500 are evident for the cohort for lung cancer and for noninfectious pulmonary diseases (including asbestosis), while being almost 300 for total cancer and about 170 for all causes of death. A statistically significant SMR of almost 200 is seen for colon-rectum cancer. Mesothelioma incidence initially shows a strong relationship with advancing time since onset of exposure and then tails off. The main concern of the study is with dose-response patterns. Response is measured by the mortality for relevant causes of death, while the direct asbestos dosage was measured in two ways. One way was the length of time worked in the factory and the other was the individual's accumulated fiber exposure, calculated by multiplying the aforementioned length of time worked by the estimated fiber exposures associated with the particular job that the worker had in the factory. Whichever measure of dosage is used, it was found that, in general, the lower the dose, the longer it took for adverse mortality to become evident and, also, the smaller the magnitude of that adverse mortality.
对新泽西州帕特森市一家1941年至1945年间开始运营的铁石棉工厂的820名男性工人进行了队列研究,观察期为开始工作后的5至40年。队列中的大多数人工作经历有限(几天、几周、几个月),不过也有一些人工作了数年,直到工厂于1954年关闭。以新泽西州白人男性作为对照人群,该队列的肺癌和非感染性肺部疾病(包括石棉沉着病)的标准化死亡比(SMR)高达500,而全癌的标准化死亡比接近300,所有死因的标准化死亡比约为170。直肠癌的标准化死亡比在统计学上显著,接近200。间皮瘤发病率最初与接触开始后的时间推进呈现出很强的相关性,随后趋于平稳。该研究主要关注剂量反应模式。反应通过相关死因的死亡率来衡量,而直接石棉剂量通过两种方式测量。一种方式是在工厂工作的时长,另一种是个体累积纤维暴露量,计算方法是将上述工作时长乘以与工人在工厂所从事的特定工作相关的估计纤维暴露量。无论采用哪种剂量测量方法,都发现一般而言,剂量越低,不良死亡率显现出来所需的时间就越长,而且不良死亡率的幅度也越小。