Middleton Sandy, Bruch Dominik, Martinez-Garduno Cintia, Dale Simeon, McNamara Maria
Professor, Nursing Research Institute, St. Vincent's Health Australia (Sydney) and Australian Catholic University, Darlinghurst, NSW, Australia.
Research Assistant, Nursing Research Institute, St. Vincent's Health Australia (Sydney) and Australian Catholic University, Darlinghurst, NSW, Australia.
Worldviews Evid Based Nurs. 2017 Dec;14(6):447-454. doi: 10.1111/wvn.12253. Epub 2017 Aug 14.
Uptake of proven interventions requires dedicated resources that may only result in local implementation, thus precluding international practice change. We explored international uptake through online dissemination of the fever, sugar, and swallow (FeSS) protocols from the Quality in Acute Stroke Care (QASC) trial, which showed decreased death and dependency by 15.7% 90-day poststroke.
To identify: (a) the clinical discipline of healthcare professionals who downloaded the QASC resources; (b) the purpose for downloading; (c) successful implementation of any or all the FeSS protocols; (d) barriers to implementation; and (e) associations with self-reported successful implementation.
A cross-sectional, online survey of those who downloaded the QASC resources between October 2011 and August 2013. Associations between implementation and participant characteristics were determined.
One-hundred and fifty-nine people from 21 countries participated. Nurses were the largest group to download the resources (n = 54, 38%), with the primary purpose to inform clinical practice (n = 97, 64%). Less than half (n = 77, 48%) downloaded, and less than a quarter (n = 38, 24%) attempted to implement all three protocols. Of those personally involved in implementation (n = 50) half reported doing so successfully for one or more protocols (n = 27, 54%) with 10 (20%) reporting successful implementation of all three protocols. Only about half (n = 13, 48%) used the proven implementation strategy with about one-third (n = 10, 29%) confirming successful uptake via audit. Implementation barriers were potential increase in nursing workload (n = 28, 56%) and lack of medical staff engagement (n = 27, 53%). Higher autonomy was associated with greater likelihood of implementation of all three protocols (p = .038).
The QASC intervention required use of all three protocols. However, less than half downloaded them all and implementation was not guided by the proven implementation strategy. While encouraging that these resources were being used to drive practice change, piecemeal implementation of a proven intervention is unlikely to improve patient outcomes.
采用已证实的干预措施需要专门的资源,而这些资源可能仅导致在当地实施,从而无法实现国际实践的改变。我们通过在线传播急性卒中护理质量(QASC)试验中的发热、血糖和吞咽(FeSS)方案来探索国际采用情况,该试验显示卒中后90天死亡和依赖率降低了15.7%。
确定:(a)下载QASC资源的医疗保健专业人员的临床学科;(b)下载的目的;(c)任何或所有FeSS方案的成功实施情况;(d)实施的障碍;以及(e)与自我报告的成功实施之间的关联。
对2011年10月至2013年8月期间下载QASC资源的人员进行横断面在线调查。确定实施情况与参与者特征之间的关联。
来自21个国家的159人参与了调查。护士是下载资源的最大群体(n = 54,38%),主要目的是为临床实践提供信息(n = 97,64%)。不到一半(n = 77,48%)的人下载了所有资源,不到四分之一(n = 38,24%)的人试图实施所有三个方案。在亲自参与实施的人员(n = 50)中,一半人报告成功实施了一个或多个方案(n = 27,54%),10人(20%)报告成功实施了所有三个方案。只有约一半(n = 13,48%)的人采用了已证实的实施策略,约三分之一(n = 10,29%)通过审核确认成功采用。实施障碍包括护理工作量可能增加(n = 28,56%)和医务人员参与度不足(n = 27,53%)。更高的自主权与实施所有三个方案的可能性更大相关(p = 0.038)。
QASC干预需要使用所有三个方案。然而,不到一半的人下载了所有方案,并且实施没有遵循已证实的实施策略。虽然这些资源被用于推动实践改变令人鼓舞,但对已证实的干预措施进行零碎实施不太可能改善患者结局。