Cámara Montaña, Muñoz van den Eynde Ana, López Cerezo José A
Complutense University of Madrid, Spain.
Research Centre for Energy, Environment and Technology (CIEMAT), Spain.
Public Underst Sci. 2018 Aug;27(6):690-707. doi: 10.1177/0963662517719172. Epub 2017 Aug 17.
Using data obtained from Spanish surveys on the public perception of science, this article presents a critical review of current practices of population profile segmentation, including the one-dimensional representation of perceived risks and benefits and of the systematic underestimation of critical attitudes to the social impact of science and technology. We use discriminant analysis to detect a somewhat hidden cluster in the Spanish population which we call 'critical engagers'. These individuals are critically and socially responsible and are not reticent about expressing concern regarding scientific-technological change. While they hold an overall positive attitude towards change of this kind, they are at the same time well aware of the risks posed by particular fields of application. We highlight the academic interest and political value of these individuals, attributing to this population a mature and intelligent stance which may well be employed in enhancing the relationship between science and society.
本文利用从西班牙关于公众对科学认知的调查中获得的数据,对当前人口特征细分的做法进行了批判性审视,包括对感知到的风险和益处的一维呈现,以及对科技社会影响的批判性态度的系统性低估。我们使用判别分析来检测西班牙人口中一个有点隐蔽的群体,我们称之为“批判性参与者”。这些人具有批判性和社会责任感,对于表达对科技变革的担忧并不沉默。虽然他们对这类变革总体持积极态度,但同时也清楚特定应用领域带来的风险。我们强调了这些人的学术价值和政治价值,认为这一群体具有成熟而明智的立场,这很可能有助于加强科学与社会之间的关系。