Liu Min, Chai Li, Luo Qiong, Ruan Maomei, Cheng Lingxiao, Lv Zhongwei, Chen Libo
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Shanghai Jiao Tong University Affiliated Sixth People's Hospital Department of Nuclear Medicine, Shanghai Tenth People's Hospital, Tongji University Department of Nuclear Medicine, Shanghai Chest Hospital, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, People's Republic of China.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2017 Aug;96(33):e7631. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000007631.
The aim of this study is to determine the contribution of neck and chest Tc-pertechnetate scan to the management of postoperative patients with suspicious metastatic differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC), particularly to the prediction of response to radioiodine (I) therapy. Just before I administration, a total of 184 postoperative DTC patients with stimulated serum thyroglobulin (ssTg) >10 ng/mL were enrolled to undergo neck and chest Tc-pertechnetate scan, which were directly compared with post-therapeutic I scan to determine the concordance of site and number of metastatic lesions. The percentage changes in ssTg between Tc-pertechnetate-avid group and Tc-pertechnetate-nonavid group were compared, and the response to I in both groups was analyzed according to the nature of Tc-pertechnetate avidity as well. The percentages of concordance between Tc-pertechnetate and I scan in detecting metastases were 65.7% and 26.0% in per-patient and per-site analyses with low unweighted kappa, respectively. Tc-pertechnetate scan led to a change in therapeutic decision making in 19/184 (10.3%) patients. In 72 patients with I-avid metastases, the ssTg in Tc-pertechnetate-avid group (n = 13) decreased significantly compared with that in Tc-pertechnetate-nonavid group (n = 59) (median: -81.56% vs -48.14%; Z = -4.276, P = .000). The difference of therapeutic response between Tc-pertechnetate-avid group and Tc-pertechnetate-nonavid group was statistically significant (χ = 8.4; P = .03). Although the consistency between Tc-pertechnetate scan before I administration and post-therapy I scan in detecting metastases is low, identifying metastases in postoperative DTC patients with elevated ssTg via Tc-pertechnetate scan prior to I therapy provides incremental value for therapeutic decision making. Notably, patients with Tc-pertechnetate-avid metastases may be more prone to benefit from I therapy than those with Tc-pertechnetate-nonavid metastases.
本研究的目的是确定颈部和胸部高锝酸盐扫描对术后可疑转移性分化型甲状腺癌(DTC)患者管理的贡献,特别是对放射性碘(I)治疗反应的预测。在给予I之前,共纳入184例术后血清促甲状腺球蛋白(ssTg)>10 ng/mL的DTC患者,进行颈部和胸部高锝酸盐扫描,并将其与治疗后的I扫描直接比较,以确定转移灶部位和数量的一致性。比较高锝酸盐摄取组和非摄取组之间ssTg的百分比变化,并根据高锝酸盐摄取的性质分析两组对I的反应。在按患者和按部位分析中,高锝酸盐扫描和I扫描在检测转移灶方面的一致性百分比分别为65.7%和26.0%,未加权kappa值较低。高锝酸盐扫描导致19/184(10.3%)的患者治疗决策发生改变。在72例有I摄取性转移灶的患者中,高锝酸盐摄取组(n = 13)的ssTg较非摄取组(n = 59)显著下降(中位数:-81.56%对-48.14%;Z = -4.276,P = .000)。高锝酸盐摄取组和非摄取组之间的治疗反应差异具有统计学意义(χ = 8.4;P = .03)。虽然给予I之前的高锝酸盐扫描与治疗后的I扫描在检测转移灶方面的一致性较低,但在I治疗前通过高锝酸盐扫描识别术后ssTg升高的DTC患者中的转移灶,可为治疗决策提供额外价值。值得注意的是,高锝酸盐摄取性转移灶的患者可能比非摄取性转移灶的患者更易从I治疗中获益。