Tsujimoto A, Barkmeier W W, Takamizawa T, Latta M A, Miayazaki M
Oper Dent. 2017 Sep/Oct;42(5):E148-E158. doi: 10.2341/16-270-L.
The relationship between the simulated gap wear and generalized wear of resin luting cements was investigated.
Five resin luting cements, G-Cem LinkForce (GL), Multilink Automix (MA), NX3 Nexus, Panavia V5 (PV), and RelyX Ultimate were evaluated and subsequently subjected to a wear challenge in a Leinfelder-Suzuki (Alabama) wear simulation device. Half of the specimens from each resin luting cement were photo-cured for 40 seconds and the other half were not photo-cured. The simulated gap and generalized wear were generated using a flat-ended stainless steel antagonist. Wear testing was performed in a water slurry of polymethyl methacrylate beads, and the simulated gap and generalized wear were determined using a noncontact profilometer (Proscan 2100) in conjunction with the Proscan and AnSur 3D software.
A strong relationship was found between the gap wear and generalized wear simulation models. The simulated gap wear and generalized wear of the resin luting cements followed similar trends in terms of both volume loss and mean depth of wear facets with each curing method. Unlike the simulated gap wear and generalized wear of GL and PV, those of MA, NX, and RU were influenced by the curing method.
The results of this study indicate that simulated gap wear of resin luting cements is very similar to simulated generalized wear. In most cases, dual curing appears to ensure greater wear resistance of resin luting cements than chemical curing alone. The wear resistance of some resin luting cements appears to be material dependent and is not influenced by the curing method.
研究树脂粘结水门汀模拟间隙磨损与总体磨损之间的关系。
对五种树脂粘结水门汀G-Cem LinkForce(GL)、Multilink Automix(MA)、NX3 Nexus、Panavia V5(PV)和RelyX Ultimate进行评估,随后在Leinfelder-Suzuki(阿拉巴马州)磨损模拟装置中进行磨损挑战试验。每种树脂粘结水门汀的一半试样光固化40秒,另一半不进行光固化。使用平头不锈钢对颌体产生模拟间隙和总体磨损。在聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯珠粒的水悬浮液中进行磨损测试,并使用非接触式轮廓仪(Proscan 2100)结合Proscan和AnSur 3D软件测定模拟间隙和总体磨损。
间隙磨损与总体磨损模拟模型之间存在密切关系。在每种固化方法下,树脂粘结水门汀的模拟间隙磨损和总体磨损在体积损失和磨损面平均深度方面均呈现相似趋势。与GL和PV的模拟间隙磨损和总体磨损不同,MA、NX和RU的模拟间隙磨损和总体磨损受固化方法的影响。
本研究结果表明,树脂粘结水门汀的模拟间隙磨损与模拟总体磨损非常相似。在大多数情况下,双重固化似乎比单独化学固化能确保树脂粘结水门汀具有更高的耐磨性。一些树脂粘结水门汀的耐磨性似乎取决于材料,不受固化方法的影响。