Kaye Sherrie-Anne, White Melanie J, Lewis Ioni
a Queensland University of Technology , Centre for Accident Research and Road Safety-Queensland (CARRS-Q) , Kelvin Grove , Queensland , Australia.
b Queensland University of Technology , Institute of Health and Biomedical Innovation , Kelvin Grove , Queensland , Australia.
Traffic Inj Prev. 2018 Feb 17;19(2):201-206. doi: 10.1080/15389588.2017.1369531. Epub 2017 Oct 23.
This study examined whether reward and punishment sensitivities, as conceptualized by Gray and McNaughton's revised reinforcement sensitivity theory (RST), influenced young female drivers' attention toward a series of positive and negative antispeeding advertisement images. Young females' increasing crash risk is associated with their engagement in risky behaviors, which, in turn, has been associated with a stronger behavioral approach system (BAS; sensitive to rewards). It was predicted that individuals with a stronger BAS would elicit larger N100 and N200 mean amplitudes (reflecting greater attention) toward the positive images. Similar associations were predicted in relation to the fight-flight-freeze system (FFFS; sensitive to punishments) for negative images.
Twenty-four female drivers (17-25 years; final N = 16) completed Corr-Cooper's RST-Personality Questionnaire, prior to undergoing an event-related potential computerized visual task (i.e., oddball paradigm) that included positive, negative, and neutral images as targets against checkerboard image distractors.
Contrary to expectations, individuals with a stronger BAS (Reward Reactivity and Impulsivity) demonstrated significantly larger N200 mean amplitudes at the Cz electrode site on presentation of the negative images than those with a weaker BAS. No other significant RST effects were found.
These findings provide some preliminary objective support for the use of negative emotion-based road safety advertisements for young females. Further, this study provides support for using psychophysiological measures to enhance understanding of traffic injury persuasion.
本研究考察了格雷和麦克诺顿修订的强化敏感性理论(RST)所概念化的奖励和惩罚敏感性,是否会影响年轻女性驾驶员对一系列正面和负面反超速广告图像的注意力。年轻女性不断增加的碰撞风险与她们从事危险行为有关,而这又与更强的行为趋近系统(BAS;对奖励敏感)有关。据预测,具有更强BAS的个体对正面图像会引发更大的N100和N200平均波幅(反映出更高的注意力)。对于负面图像,预计在战斗-逃跑-冻结系统(FFFS;对惩罚敏感)方面会有类似的关联。
24名女性驾驶员(17 - 25岁;最终样本量N = 16)在进行一项与事件相关的电位计算机视觉任务(即oddball范式)之前,完成了科尔-库珀的RST-人格问卷,该任务包括以正面、负面和中性图像作为目标,以棋盘图像作为干扰项。
与预期相反,具有更强BAS(奖励反应性和冲动性)的个体在呈现负面图像时,在Cz电极部位的N200平均波幅显著大于BAS较弱的个体。未发现其他显著的RST效应。
这些发现为针对年轻女性使用基于负面情绪的道路安全广告提供了一些初步的客观支持。此外,本研究为使用心理生理测量方法来增强对交通伤害劝导的理解提供了支持。