Bagarani M, Albertini V, Anzà M, Barlattani A, Bracci F, Cucchiara G, Gizzonio D, Grassini G, Mari T, Procacciante F
Ital J Surg Sci. 1987;17(1):21-6.
A multicenter double-blind clinical trial was undertaken to evaluate the efficacy of a short-term somatostatin treatment versus a short-term vasopressin treatment on acute hemorrhage from esophageal varices in patients with liver cirrhosis and portal hypertension. Forty-nine patients with massive hemorrhage and endoscopic diagnosis of bleeding esophageal varices completed the study. Patients were randomly assigned to somatostatin treatment (24 patients: 250 micrograms/hr i.v. for 48 hrs) or vasopressin treatment (25 patients: 0.1 U/min i.v. for 48 hrs). The Sengstaken-Blakemore tube was utilized, when needed, for a six hour period. In case of failure the patients were crossed-over to the other treatment. Patients in whom the bleeding stopped at 48 hrs, were randomly assigned to somatostatin (250 micrograms/hr i.v.) or placebo for seven days. Bleeding stopped in 68% of patients treated with somatostatin and in 28% of patients treated with vasopressin (p less than 0.0013). Mortality rate was lower, but not significantly so, in the somatostatin group compared to the vasopressin group. No differences were noted between somatostatin and placebo in preventing bleeding recurrences. These data suggest that somatostatin, when combined if necessary with a 6 hour period of balloon tamponade, is more effective than vasopressin at low doses in controlling severe hemorrhage from esophageal varices in patients with liver cirrhosis and portal hypertension. A clinical use of somatostatin seems to be indicated in these patients.
一项多中心双盲临床试验旨在评估短期生长抑素治疗与短期血管加压素治疗对肝硬化和门静脉高压患者食管静脉曲张急性出血的疗效。49例大量出血且经内镜诊断为食管静脉曲张出血的患者完成了该研究。患者被随机分配至生长抑素治疗组(24例患者:以250微克/小时静脉输注,持续48小时)或血管加压素治疗组(25例患者:以0.1单位/分钟静脉输注,持续48小时)。必要时使用Sengstaken-Blakemore管,持续6小时。若治疗失败,患者交叉至另一种治疗。出血在48小时停止的患者被随机分配至生长抑素组(以250微克/小时静脉输注)或安慰剂组,持续7天。生长抑素治疗组68%的患者出血停止,血管加压素治疗组为28%(p<0.0013)。与血管加压素组相比,生长抑素组的死亡率较低,但无显著差异。生长抑素与安慰剂在预防出血复发方面无差异。这些数据表明,生长抑素在必要时联合6小时气囊压迫,在控制肝硬化和门静脉高压患者食管静脉曲张严重出血方面比低剂量血管加压素更有效。这些患者似乎有必要临床应用生长抑素。