Gøtzsche P C, Gjørup I E, Bonnén H, Brahe N E, Becker P U, Burcharth F
Medicinsk gastroenterologisk afdeling, Hvidovre Hospital.
Ugeskr Laeger. 1996 Apr 22;158(17):2393-6.
We studied whether somatostatin or its derivative, octreotide, is more effective than placebo in the treatment of bleeding oesophageal varices in a randomised, double-blind trial and a meta-analysis with blinded data analysis and manuscript writing. Patients suspected of bleeding from oesophageal varices and of having cirrhosis of the liver were eligible. Eighty-six patients were randomised; 16 died in each group within six weeks (95% confidence interval (CI) for difference in mortality -19% to 22%). There were no differences between somatostatin and placebo in median number of blood transfusions (8 vs 5, p = 0.07, CI 0 to 4 transfusions) or in numbers of patients who needed balloon tamponade (16 vs 13, p = 0.54, CI -11% to 28%). In a meta-analysis of three trials, involving 290 patients, somatostatin had no effect on survival compared with placebo (p = 0.59, odds ratio 1.16, CI 0.67 to 2.01). For blood transfusions and use of balloon tamponade there was heterogeneity between the trials with no convincing evidence in favour of somatostatin.
我们在一项随机、双盲试验以及一项采用盲态数据分析和撰写论文的荟萃分析中,研究了生长抑素或其衍生物奥曲肽在治疗食管静脉曲张出血方面是否比安慰剂更有效。疑似食管静脉曲张出血且患有肝硬化的患者符合入选条件。86例患者被随机分组;每组在六周内有16例死亡(死亡率差异的95%置信区间为-19%至22%)。生长抑素组和安慰剂组在输血中位数(8次对5次,p = 0.07,置信区间为0至4次输血)或需要气囊压迫止血的患者数量(16例对13例,p = 0.54,置信区间为-11%至28%)方面均无差异。在一项涉及290例患者的三项试验的荟萃分析中,与安慰剂相比,生长抑素对生存率无影响(p = 0.59,比值比1.16,置信区间为0.67至2.01)。在输血和使用气囊压迫止血方面,各试验之间存在异质性,没有令人信服的证据支持生长抑素。