Johnsen Birger, Nøhr Kristoffer B, Duez Christophe H V, Ebbesen Mads Q
1 Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, Aarhus University Hospital, Aarhus, Denmark.
2 Research Centre for Emergency Medicine, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark.
Clin EEG Neurosci. 2017 Nov;48(6):428-437. doi: 10.1177/1550059417726475. Epub 2017 Aug 28.
EEG reactivity (EEG-R) is regarded as an important parameter in coma prognosis but knowledge is sparse on the nature of EEG changes due to different kinds of stimulation and their prognostic significance. EEG-R was quantified in a study of 39 comatose neurosurgical patients. Six 30-second standardized visual, auditory, and painful stimulations were applied. EEG-R in the delta, theta, alpha, and beta band was normalized in z-scores as the power of a stimulation epoch relative to average power of 6 resting epochs. Outcome measure was 3 months Glasgow Outcome Scale. Increase in EEG activity was related to poor outcome, was more common (13.4% of tests), and grew continuously during the 30-second stimulation epoch. Decrease in EEG activity was related to good outcome, was rarer (2.5%), and peaked around 15 seconds. Pain was the most provocative stimulation (20.4%) followed by sound (8.7%) and eye-opening (6.7%). Discrimination between good (n = 6) and poor (n = 33) outcome was best in the theta and alpha bands for pain stimulation in the first 10-20 seconds and for sound stimulation in the first 5 to 10 seconds, eye-opening did not discriminate. Increase in activity predicted poor outcome with a high specificity 100% (CI = 52%-100%) and a modest sensitivity of 39% (CI = 23%-58%). Decrease in activity predicted good outcome with a high specificity of 100% (CI = 87%-100%) and a modest sensitivity of 33% (CI = 6%-76%). This quantitative study reveals new knowledge about the nature of EEG-R, which contribute to the development of more reliable and objective clinical procedures for outcome prediction.
脑电图反应性(EEG-R)被视为昏迷预后的一个重要参数,但对于不同类型刺激引起的脑电图变化的性质及其预后意义,人们了解甚少。在一项针对39名昏迷神经外科患者的研究中,对EEG-R进行了量化。应用了六种30秒的标准化视觉、听觉和疼痛刺激。将δ、θ、α和β波段的EEG-R标准化为z分数,即刺激时段的功率相对于6个静息时段平均功率的比值。结局指标为3个月时的格拉斯哥预后量表。脑电图活动增加与不良预后相关,更为常见(占测试的13.),并且在30秒的刺激时段内持续增加。脑电图活动减少与良好预后相关,较为罕见(2.5%),并在15秒左右达到峰值。疼痛是最具刺激性的刺激(20.4%),其次是声音(8.7%)和睁眼(6.7%)。在θ和α波段,对于前10至20秒的疼痛刺激以及前5至10秒的声音刺激,区分良好(n = 6)和不良(n = 33)预后的效果最佳,睁眼刺激则无法区分。活动增加预测不良预后具有高特异性100%(CI = 52%-100%)和中等敏感性39%(CI = 23%-58%)。活动减少预测良好预后具有高特异性100%(CI = 87%-100%)和中等敏感性33%(CI = 6%-76%)。这项定量研究揭示了有关EEG-R性质的新知识,这有助于开发更可靠、客观的临床结局预测程序。