The Influence of Tai Chi Exercise on Proprioception in Patients with Knee Osteoarthritis: Results from a Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial.

PURPOSE

Previous long-term observational studies found that Tai Chi practitioners had better knee-joint proprioceptive acuity versus controls in an older population. We evaluated the effects of Tai Chi for knee-joint proprioception in knee osteoarthritis (OA) in a randomized controlled trial.

METHODS

We randomized 40 eligible individuals (age > 55, BMI ≤ 40 kg/m with knee pain on most days of the previous month and tibiofemoral OA (K/L grade ≥2) to Tai Chi (10 modified forms from classical Yang style) or to an attention control (stretching and wellness education). The 60 minute intervention sessions occurred twice-weekly for 12 weeks. The knee joint proprioception was measured using a Biometrics™ electrogoniometer with an ADU301 angle display unit during each assessment visit. Three test angles (30, 45 and 60 degrees) were evaluated with each subject in a sitting position taken as neutral (0 degrees). The mean error (absolute angle error) between the actual and replicated angles was calculated for each of the three test angles. The Tai Chi and control groups were compared by intention-to-treat using t-tests.

RESULTS

The participants had a mean age of 65 y (SD 7.8), a mean disease duration of 10 y (SD 7.6), a mean BMI of 30.0 kg/m (SD 4.8), and median K/L grade 4; 75% were female, 70% were white. The participants in the Tai Chi intervention exhibited significantly improved proprioception at 30 degrees, but not at 45 or 60 degrees, at 12 weeks. Patients who continued Tai Chi practice after 12 weeks also reported no significant improvements in knee proprioception at 24 and 48 weeks.

CONCLUSION

Tai Chi appears to be beneficial for knee proprioception in people with severe knee OA at a 30 degree test angle immediately following 12 weeks of practice. However, we were unable to demonstrate that Tai Chi has any long-term effects on knee proprioception, nor were we able to find any effects on proprioception at larger test angles (45 and 60 degrees). Standardized and reproducible measures for knee proprioception should be explored in future research.