Vagwala Meghana Kasturi, Bicquelet Aude, Didziokaite Gabija, Coomber Ross, Corrigan Oonagh, Singh Ilina
Trinity College of Arts and Sciences, Duke University, P.O. Box 95790, Duke University West Campus, Durham, NC 27708 USA.
NatCen Social Research, 35 Northampton Square, London, EC1V 0AX UK.
Neuroethics. 2017;10(3):389-403. doi: 10.1007/s12152-017-9336-5. Epub 2017 Jul 6.
Few empirical studies in the UK have examined the complex social patterns and values behind quantitative estimates of the prevalence of pharmacological cognitive enhancement (PCE). We conducted a qualitative investigation of the social dynamics and moral attitudes that shape PCE practices among university students in two major metropolitan areas in the UK. Our thematic analysis of eight focus groups ( = 66) suggests a moral ecology that operates within the social infrastructure of the university. We find that PCE resilience among UK university students is mediated by normative and cultural judgments disfavoring competitiveness and prescription drug taking. PCE risk can be augmented by social factors such as soft peer pressure and normalization of enhancement within social and institutional networks. We suggest that moral ecological dynamics should be viewed as key mechanisms of PCE risk and resilience in universities. Effective PCE governance within universities should therefore attend to developing further understanding of the moral ecologies of PCE.
在英国,很少有实证研究探讨药物认知增强(PCE)患病率定量估计背后复杂的社会模式和价值观。我们对英国两个主要大都市地区大学生中形成PCE行为的社会动态和道德态度进行了定性调查。我们对八个焦点小组(n = 66)的主题分析表明,存在一种在大学社会基础设施内运作的道德生态。我们发现,英国大学生对PCE的抵抗力是由不利于竞争和服用处方药的规范和文化判断所调节的。PCE风险可能会因社会因素而增加,如温和的同伴压力以及社会和机构网络中增强行为的常态化。我们建议,道德生态动态应被视为大学中PCE风险和抵抗力的关键机制。因此,大学内有效的PCE治理应致力于进一步理解PCE的道德生态。