Shafiei Leili, Taymoori Parvaneh, Maleki Afshin, Nouri Bijan
Environmental Health Research Center, Kurdistan University of Medical Sciences, Sanandaj, Iran.
Social Determinants of Health Research Center, Kurdistan University of Medical Sciences, Sanandaj, Iran.
J Clin Diagn Res. 2017 Jul;11(7):JC01-JC06. doi: 10.7860/JCDR/2017/26784.10262. Epub 2017 Jul 1.
The effect of instructional models on the changing behaviour of consuming contaminated rice with toxic metals has not been investigated in Iran yet.
To compare effect of Health Belief Model (HBM) and Ecological (ECO) social model on decreasing the consumption of rice contaminated with toxic metals.
The study aimed at implementing a six-month interventionist program among three groups (HBM, ECO and Control). The study population comprised of 240 women, aged 18 to 50. Questionnaires were distributed which consisted of demographic information, knowledge, constructs of the models, performance of rice consumption, and the manner of rice cooking. In HBM group participants were individually provided with instructions based on HBM. However, in ECO group participants received the instruction through social networks consisted of mothers, sisters, family members, and colleagues.
The results of Wilcoxon test indicated improvements in people's diet including a significant increase in the number of women consuming rice without toxic metals, a significant reduction in the number of women consuming rice contaminated with toxic metals in both intervention groups. On the other hand, such an improvement was not observed in the control group. The results of repeated measures' analysis of variance suggested further improvement in healthy diet in ECO group rather than HBM group after the completion of the environmental intervention.
Both methods of instructional intervention caused changes in the diet of people regarding the consumption of rice free from toxic metals and changes in the manner of cooking from Kateh (steaming rice) to Pilaw (draining rice). Development of social support had probably a more effective role on the improvement of people's diet.
在伊朗,尚未对教学模式对食用受有毒金属污染大米的行为变化的影响进行研究。
比较健康信念模型(HBM)和生态(ECO)社会模型对减少食用受有毒金属污染大米的影响。
该研究旨在对三组(HBM组、ECO组和对照组)实施为期六个月的干预计划。研究对象为240名年龄在18至50岁之间的女性。发放了问卷,内容包括人口统计学信息、知识、模型构建、大米消费行为以及大米烹饪方式。在HBM组,根据HBM为参与者提供个性化指导。然而,在ECO组,参与者通过由母亲、姐妹、家庭成员和同事组成的社交网络接受指导。
威尔科克森检验结果表明,人们的饮食有所改善,包括两个干预组中食用无毒金属大米的女性数量显著增加,食用受有毒金属污染大米的女性数量显著减少。另一方面,对照组未观察到这种改善。重复测量方差分析结果表明,环境干预完成后,ECO组的健康饮食改善程度高于HBM组。
两种教学干预方法都导致了人们在食用无毒金属大米的饮食方面的变化,以及烹饪方式从卡泰(蒸米饭)到皮洛(沥干米饭)的变化。社会支持的发展可能对改善人们的饮食起到了更有效的作用。