Windle Gill, Gregory Samantha, Howson-Griffiths Teri, Newman Andrew, O'Brien Dave, Goulding Anna
Dementia Services Development Centre, School of Healthcare Sciences, Bangor University, Wales.
School of Psychology, Aston University, England.
Dementia (London). 2018 Aug;17(6):702-727. doi: 10.1177/1471301217726613. Epub 2017 Sep 15.
Despite the growing international innovations for visual arts interventions in dementia care, limited attention has been paid to their theoretical basis. In response, this paper explores how and why visual art interventions in dementia care influence changes in outcomes. The theory building process consists of a realist review of primary research on visual art programmes. This aims to uncover what works, for whom, how, why and in what circumstances. We undertook a qualitative exploration of stakeholder perspectives of art programmes, and then synthesised these two pieces of work alongside broader theory to produce a conceptual framework for intervention development, further research and practice. This suggests effective programmes are realised through essential attributes of two key conditions (provocative and stimulating aesthetic experience; dynamic and responsive artistic practice). These conditions are important for cognitive, social and individual responses, leading to benefits for people with early to more advanced dementia. This work represents a starting point at identifying theories of change for arts interventions, and for further research to critically examine, refine and strengthen the evidence base for the arts in dementia care. Understanding the theoretical basis of interventions is important for service development, evaluation and implementation.
尽管国际上针对痴呆症护理中的视觉艺术干预措施的创新不断增加,但对其理论基础的关注却有限。作为回应,本文探讨了痴呆症护理中的视觉艺术干预措施如何以及为何会影响结果的变化。理论构建过程包括对视觉艺术项目的初步研究进行现实主义综述。其目的是揭示什么有效、对谁有效、如何有效、为何有效以及在何种情况下有效。我们对艺术项目的利益相关者观点进行了定性探索,然后将这两项工作与更广泛的理论相结合,以生成一个用于干预发展、进一步研究和实践的概念框架。这表明有效的项目是通过两个关键条件的基本属性实现的(激发性和刺激性的审美体验;动态且响应性的艺术实践)。这些条件对于认知、社会和个人反应很重要,从而为早期至晚期痴呆症患者带来益处。这项工作是确定艺术干预措施变革理论的起点,也是进一步研究以批判性地审视、完善和加强痴呆症护理中艺术的证据基础的起点。理解干预措施的理论基础对于服务发展、评估和实施很重要。