Yang Na, Ma Rong, Hu Si-Yuan, Liu Hong, Yan Hui-Min, Xiang Xi-Xiong, Wang Xue-Feng, Chen Yin-Bo, Chen Yu-Yan, Jiao Fu-Yong, Ding Ying, Huang Hao, Wang Ling-di
Tianjin University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Tianjin 300193, China.
The First Hospital Affiliated of Tianjin University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Tianjin 300193, China.
Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi. 2016 Aug;41(16):3100-3106. doi: 10.4268/cjcmm20161627.
To evaluate the efficacy and safety of Choudongning (CDN)capsule in children with Tourette's syndrome of spleen deficiency and phlegm accumulation through a randomized double-blind three-arm controlled phase Ⅲ study in 588 patients from 8 hospitals. The included patients were randomly divided into test group, positive control group and placebo group at the ratio of 3∶1∶1. Patients in the test group orally took CDN capsules and simulated Tiapridal tablets; the patients in positive control group took Tiapridal tablets and simulated CDN capsules; whereas the patients in placebo group orally took the simulated agents of the above two drugs. The treatment course was 6 weeks for three groups. The global grading rates, YGTSS scores and its factor scores, the degree of social function damage, as well as traditional Chinese medicine syndrome efficacy were evaluated as the outcome measures on efficacy. The AEs/ADRs, vital signs and laboratory testing were observed as outcome measures on safety. The total effective rate of YGTSS was 75.92% in the test group, 72.65% in the positive control group, and 37.29% in the placebo group. Non inferiority test stands between the test group and the positive control group, and they were superior to placebo group in efficacy with statistical difference. Significant difference had also been found among the 3 groups in YGTSS tics score, motor tics score, vocal tics, degree of social function damage and traditional Chinese medicine syndrome efficacy. During the study, there were 5 (1.42%)ADRs in the test group, 10 (8.55%)in the positive control group and 3 (2.54%)in the placebo group. The incidence of ADRs in the test group was lower than that in the positive control group, with statistical difference. It is clear to say that CDN capsule can effectively treat the Tourette's syndrome of spleen deficiency and phlegm accumulation. Its efficacy is not inferior to the commonly used Tiapridal tablets, with even less adverse reactions, so it has clinical application value.
通过对来自8家医院的588例患者进行随机双盲三臂对照Ⅲ期研究,评估抽动宁(CDN)胶囊治疗脾虚痰聚型抽动秽语综合征患儿的疗效和安全性。将纳入的患者按3∶1∶1的比例随机分为试验组、阳性对照组和安慰剂组。试验组患者口服CDN胶囊并模拟泰必利片;阳性对照组患者服用泰必利片并模拟CDN胶囊;而安慰剂组患者口服上述两种药物的模拟剂。三组治疗疗程均为6周。以总体分级率、耶鲁综合抽动严重程度量表(YGTSS)评分及其因子评分、社会功能损害程度以及中医证候疗效作为疗效的观察指标。观察不良事件/药物不良反应(AEs/ADRs)、生命体征和实验室检查结果作为安全性的观察指标。试验组YGTSS总有效率为75.92%,阳性对照组为72.65%,安慰剂组为37.29%。试验组与阳性对照组进行非劣效性检验,二者在疗效上均优于安慰剂组,差异有统计学意义。三组在YGTSS抽动评分、运动性抽动评分、发声性抽动、社会功能损害程度及中医证候疗效方面也存在显著差异。研究期间,试验组出现5例(1.42%)药物不良反应,阳性对照组出现10例(8.55%),安慰剂组出现3例(2.54%)。试验组药物不良反应发生率低于阳性对照组,差异有统计学意义。可见,CDN胶囊能有效治疗脾虚痰聚型抽动秽语综合征。其疗效不劣于常用的泰必利片,且不良反应更少,具有临床应用价值。