Exercise Hemodynamic Laboratory, School of Physical Education and Sport, University of São Paulo, São Paulo,Brazil.
Department of Physical Education - Governador Valadares, Federal University of Juiz de Fora, Minas Gerais, Brazil.
Int J Sports Med. 2017 Nov;38(13):1029-1034. doi: 10.1055/s-0043-118009. Epub 2017 Sep 18.
This study determined the reproducibility of post-exercise hypotension (PEH) calculated by the following methods: PEH_I=post-exercise BP - pre-exercise BP; PEH_II=post-exercise BP - post-control BP; and PEH_III=[(post-exercise BP - pre-exercise BP)-(post-control BP - pre-control BP)]. Twenty-five participants underwent four sessions divided in two blocks (test and retest). Each block consisted of one exercise and one control session. BP pressure was measured before and after the interventions. The presence of systematic error (paired t-tests), reliability [intraclass coefficient correlation (ICC)], and agreement [typical error (TE) and minimal detectable difference (MDD)] were evaluated. PEHs calculated by the three methods were similar between test and retest. For systolic PEH, ICC was>0.74, TE ranged from 2.6 to 4.6 mmHg and MDD from 7.2 to 12.8 mmHg for the three methods. For diastolic PEH, ICC was<0.48, TE ranged from 3.5 to 5.6 mmHg and MDD from 9.8 to 15.4 mmHg for the three methods. Thus, systolic PEH calculated by the three methods has good/excellent reliability, while diastolic PEH has fair/poor reliability. Regarding agreement, TE and MDD varied among the methods, which implies that the specific parameters given for each method should be used to estimate sample sizes for studies and the minimal individual difference considered real when comparing PEHs.
本研究通过以下方法确定运动后低血压(PEH)的可重复性:PEH_I=运动后血压-运动前血压;PEH_II=运动后血压-运动后对照血压;PEH_III=[(运动后血压-运动前血压)-(运动后对照血压-运动前对照血压)]。25 名参与者进行了四组测试,分为两组(测试和复测)。每组由一次运动和一次对照测试组成。干预前后测量血压。评估了系统误差的存在(配对 t 检验)、可靠性[组内系数相关(ICC)]和一致性[典型误差(TE)和最小可检测差异(MDD)]。三种方法计算的 PEH 在测试和复测之间相似。对于收缩压 PEH,ICC 大于 0.74,TE 范围为 2.6 至 4.6mmHg,MDD 范围为 7.2 至 12.8mmHg,三种方法均如此。对于舒张压 PEH,ICC 小于 0.48,TE 范围为 3.5 至 5.6mmHg,MDD 范围为 9.8 至 15.4mmHg,三种方法均如此。因此,三种方法计算的收缩压 PEH 具有良好/优秀的可靠性,而舒张压 PEH 具有一般/较差的可靠性。关于一致性,TE 和 MDD 在方法之间存在差异,这意味着在估计研究样本量时应使用每个方法的特定参数,并在比较 PEH 时考虑特定方法的最小个体差异。