van Schendel Rachèl V, van El Carla G, Pajkrt Eva, Henneman Lidewij, Cornel Martina C
Department of Clinical Genetics, Section of Community Genetics, Amsterdam Public Health research institute, VU University Medical Center, P.O. Box 7057, 1007, MB, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Fetal Medicine Unit, Academic Medical Centre, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2017 Sep 19;17(1):670. doi: 10.1186/s12913-017-2618-0.
Since the introduction of non-invasive prenatal testing (NIPT) in 2011, mainly by commercial companies, a growing demand for NIPT from the public and healthcare professionals has been putting pressure on the healthcare systems of various countries. This study identifies the challenges of establishing a responsible implementation of NIPT for aneuploidy in prenatal healthcare, by looking at the Netherlands.
A mixed methods approach involving 13 stakeholder interviews, document analysis and (participatory) observations of the Dutch NIPT Consortium meetings were used. The Diffusion of Innovation Theory and a Network of Actors model were used to interpret the findings.
Implementation of NIPT was facilitated by several factors. The set-up of a national NIPT Consortium enabled discussion and collaboration between stakeholders. Moreover, it led to the plan to offer NIPT through a nationwide research setting (TRIDENT studies), which created a learning phase for careful implementation. The Dutch legal context was perceived as a delaying factor, but eventually gave room for the parties involved to organise themselves and their practices.
This study shows that implementing advanced technologies with profound effects on prenatal care benefit from a learning phase that allows time to carefully evaluate the technical performance and women's experiences and to enable public debate. Such a coordinated learning phase, involving all stakeholders, will stimulate the process of responsible and sustainable implementation.
自2011年主要由商业公司引入无创产前检测(NIPT)以来,公众和医疗保健专业人员对NIPT的需求不断增加,给各国的医疗保健系统带来了压力。本研究通过考察荷兰,确定了在产前保健中对非整倍体进行NIPT的负责任实施所面临的挑战。
采用了一种混合方法,包括13次利益相关者访谈、文件分析以及对荷兰NIPT联盟会议的(参与式)观察。运用创新扩散理论和行为者网络模型来解释研究结果。
NIPT的实施受到了几个因素的推动。国家NIPT联盟的设立促进了利益相关者之间的讨论与合作。此外,这导致了通过全国性研究项目(TRIDENT研究)提供NIPT的计划,为谨慎实施创造了一个学习阶段。荷兰的法律环境被视为一个延迟因素,但最终为相关各方提供了自我组织和实践的空间。
本研究表明,对产前护理有深远影响的先进技术的实施受益于一个学习阶段,该阶段允许有时间仔细评估技术性能和女性的体验,并进行公开辩论。这样一个涉及所有利益相关者的协调学习阶段将促进负责任和可持续实施的进程。