Geiger Brenda, Fischer Michael
1 Western Galilee College, Acre, Israel.
2 Norfolk State University, Virginia Beach, VA, USA.
Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol. 2018 Jul;62(9):2601-2623. doi: 10.1177/0306624X17731830. Epub 2017 Sep 21.
This study invited 10 of the 22 sex offenders enrolled in a prison-based rehabilitation program in one of the prisons in Israel to engage in the two first of the 4-D ( Discover, Dream, Design, and Deliver) stages of the Appreciative Inquiry . Consistent with the responsivity principle, and the IA tenets, program participants were interviewed to Discover components to which they were responsive and Dream/envision additional ones that would increase engagement and progress. Content analysis of the interviews indicated that despite the initial decision to enrol based on external incentives, participants eventually engaged in group therapy and expressed the desire to understand and regulate their sexual behaviour. While the the modules of Cognitive Behabioral Group Therapy (CBT) were viewed as assets, the lack of sufficient recruitment criteria, the large therapy group size, and its open-ended structure were mentioned as impediments reaching therapeutic goals. Social workers/therapists were criticized for their request that they be informers, and for their accusative therapeutic style whenever sexual issues were broached. Recommendations derived from the offenders' narrative were to increase staff professionalism to create a therapeutic alliance that promotes trust and open communication. Criminal justice practitioners may then take up the challenge of the never-ending process of Appreciative Inquiry to Design and Deliver program components envisioned by the participants to increase participants' responsivity to the program and thus its effectiveness.
本研究邀请了以色列一所监狱中参加基于监狱的康复项目的22名性犯罪者中的10人参与赏识性探询4 - D(发现、梦想、设计和交付)阶段的前两个阶段。与响应性原则和赏识性探询的宗旨一致,对项目参与者进行了访谈,以发现他们有响应的组成部分,并梦想/设想其他能增加参与度和进展的部分。访谈的内容分析表明,尽管最初是基于外部激励因素决定参与项目,但参与者最终参与了团体治疗,并表达了理解和规范自己性行为的愿望。虽然认知行为团体治疗(CBT)的模块被视为有益之处,但缺乏足够的招募标准、治疗团体规模过大及其开放式结构被提及是实现治疗目标的障碍。社会工作者/治疗师因其要求参与者充当告密者以及每当提及性问题时采用指责性的治疗方式而受到批评。从犯罪者的叙述中得出的建议是提高工作人员的专业水平,以建立促进信任和开放沟通的治疗联盟。刑事司法从业者随后可能会接受赏识性探询这一永无止境过程的挑战,以设计和交付参与者设想的项目组成部分,从而提高参与者对项目的响应性,进而提高其有效性。