Saleeb Susan F, McLaughlin Sarah R, Graham Dionne A, Friedman Kevin G, Fulton David R
Department of Cardiology, Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Clinical Research Program, Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Congenit Heart Dis. 2018 Jan;13(1):46-51. doi: 10.1111/chd.12539. Epub 2017 Sep 24.
Using a Standardized Clinical Assessment and Management Plan (SCAMP) for pediatric patients presenting to clinic with chest pain, we evaluated the cost impact associated with implementation of the care algorithm. Prior to introduction of the SCAMP, we analyzed charges for 406 patients with chest pain, seen in 2009, and predicted 21% reduction of overall charges had the SCAMP methodology been used. The SCAMP recommended an echocardiogram for history, examination, or ECG findings suggestive of a cardiac etiology for chest pain.
Resource utilization was reviewed for 1517 patients (7-21 years) enrolled in the SCAMP from July 2010 to April 2014.
Compared to the 2009 historic cohort, patients evaluated by the SCAMP had higher rates of exertional chest pain (45% vs 37%) and positive family history (5% vs 1%). The SCAMP cohort had fewer abnormal physical examination findings (1% vs 6%) and abnormal electrocardiograms (3% vs 5%). Echocardiogram use increased in the SCAMP cohort compared to the 2009 historic cohort (45% vs 41%), whereas all other ancillary testing was reduced: exercise stress testing (4% SCAMP vs 28% historic), Holter (4% vs 7%), event monitors (3% vs 10%), and MRI (1% vs 2%). Total charges were reduced by 22% ($822 625) by use of the Chest Pain SCAMP, despite a higher percentage of patients for whom echocardiogram was recommended compared to the historic cohort.
The Chest Pain SCAMP effectively streamlines cardiac testing and reduces resource utilization. Further reductions can be made by algorithm refinement regarding echocardiograms for exertional symptoms.
我们使用标准化临床评估与管理计划(SCAMP)对因胸痛前来诊所就诊的儿科患者进行评估,以评估实施该护理算法所带来的成本影响。在引入SCAMP之前,我们分析了2009年就诊的406例胸痛患者的费用,并预测若采用SCAMP方法,总费用将降低21%。SCAMP建议对有胸痛病史、经检查或心电图结果提示为心脏病因的患者进行超声心动图检查。
回顾了2010年7月至2014年4月纳入SCAMP的1517例(7至21岁)患者的资源利用情况。
与2009年的历史队列相比,采用SCAMP评估的患者运动性胸痛发生率更高(45%对37%),家族史阳性率更高(5%对1%)。SCAMP队列的体格检查异常结果(1%对6%)和心电图异常(3%对5%)较少。与2009年的历史队列相比,SCAMP队列中超声心动图的使用增加了(45%对41%),而所有其他辅助检查均减少:运动负荷试验(SCAMP组为4%,历史队列组为28%)、动态心电图监测(4%对7%)、事件监测仪(3%对10%)和磁共振成像(1%对2%)。尽管与历史队列相比,建议进行超声心动图检查的患者比例更高,但使用胸痛SCAMP使总费用降低了22%(822,625美元)。
胸痛SCAMP有效地简化了心脏检查并减少了资源利用。通过对运动症状的超声心动图检查算法进行优化,可进一步降低费用。