Rathod Rahul H, Jurgen Brittney, Hamershock Rose A, Friedman Kevin G, Marshall Audrey C, Samnaliev Mihail, Graham Dionne A, Jenkins Kathy, Lock James E, Powell Andrew J
Department of Cardiology, Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Department of Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Congenit Heart Dis. 2017 Dec;12(6):768-776. doi: 10.1111/chd.12508. Epub 2017 Jun 28.
Standardized Clinical Assessment and Management Plans (SCAMPs) are a quality improvement initiative designed to reduce unnecessary utilization, decrease practice variation, and improve patient outcomes. We created a novel methodology, the SCAMP managed episode of care (SMEOC), which encompasses multiple encounters to assess the impact of the arterial switch operation (ASO) SCAMP on total costs.
All ASO SCAMP patients (dates March 2009 to July 2015) were compared to a control group of ASO patients (January 2001 to February 2009). Patients were divided into "younger" (<2 years) and "older" (2-18 years) subgroups. Utilization included all cardiology visits, tests, and procedures. Standardized costs were applied to each unit of utilization.
There were 100 historical and 63 SCAMP patients in the younger subgroup, and 163 historical and 165 SCAMP patients in the older subgroup. In the younger subgroup, the SCAMP had a 28% reduction in outpatient clinic visits (P < .001), a 52% reduction in chest radiographs (P < .001), a 21% reduction in electrocardiograms (P < .001), and a 30% total reduction in costs. In the older subgroup, the SCAMP had a 21% reduction in outpatient clinic visits (P < .001), a 20% reduction in chest radiographs (P = .05), a 10% reduction in echocardiograms (P = .05), a 25% reduction in exercise stress tests (P = .01), and a 14% total reduction in costs. The total cost savings of the ASO SCAMP was $216 649 in the first 6 years of the SCAMP. There was no difference in clinical outcomes between the historical and SCAMP cohorts.
SCAMPs can improve resource utilization and reduce costs after the ASO operation while maintaining quality of care.
标准化临床评估与管理计划(SCAMPs)是一项质量改进举措,旨在减少不必要的医疗资源利用,减少医疗实践差异,并改善患者治疗效果。我们创建了一种新颖的方法,即SCAMP管理的护理事件(SMEOC),它涵盖多次就诊以评估动脉调转手术(ASO)SCAMP对总成本的影响。
将所有ASO SCAMP患者(2009年3月至2015年7月)与一组ASO对照患者(2001年1月至2009年2月)进行比较。患者被分为“较年轻”(<2岁)和“较年长”(2 - 18岁)亚组。医疗资源利用包括所有心脏病学就诊、检查和治疗。将标准化成本应用于每个医疗资源利用单元。
较年轻亚组中有100例历史对照患者和63例SCAMP患者,较年长亚组中有163例历史对照患者和165例SCAMP患者。在较年轻亚组中,SCAMP使门诊就诊次数减少了28%(P <.001),胸部X光检查减少了52%(P <.001),心电图检查减少了21%(P <.001),总成本降低了30%。在较年长亚组中,SCAMP使门诊就诊次数减少了21%(P <.001),胸部X光检查减少了20%(P =.05),超声心动图检查减少了10%(P =.05),运动负荷试验减少了25%(P =.01),总成本降低了14%。在SCAMP实施的前6年中,ASO SCAMP节省的总成本为216,649美元。历史对照队列和SCAMP队列之间的临床结局没有差异。
SCAMPs可以在维持医疗质量的同时,改善ASO手术后的资源利用并降低成本。