Baumgarten R K, Carter C E, Reynolds W J, Brown J L, DeVera H V
Anesthesia and Operative Service, Landstuhl Army Regional Medical Center, FRG.
Can J Anaesth. 1988 Jan;35(1):5-11. doi: 10.1007/BF03010536.
Results of a series of controlled, randomized, double-blind trials investigating intubation conditions with priming sequences of nondepolarizing relaxants are reported. In Phase I of the study the groups received: Group A, tubocurarine (DTC) 3 mg + succinylcholine 1.5 mg.kg-1, Group B, atracurium 0.05 mg.kg-1 + 0.35 mg.kg-1, Group C, vecuronium, 0.01 mg.kg-1 + 0.07 mg.kg-1; in Phase II: Group D, no relaxant, Group E, DTC 0.05 mg.kg-1 + vecuronium 0.07 mg.kg-1, Group F, vecuronium 0.01 mg.kg-1 + vecuronium 0.12 mg.kg-1; in Phase III, Group G, DTC 3 mg + succinylcholine 1.5 mg.kg-1, Group H, vecuronium 0.01 mg.kg-1 + 0.09 mg.kg-1, Group I vecuronium 0.1 mg.kg-1 as a single bolus. Intubation conditions were assessed at 60 seconds. A seven-minute priming interval was used in Phase I and II and a four-minute interval was used in Phase III. Priming produced significantly better intubating conditions than an equivalent single bolus; however, intubating conditions with priming did not appear to match the uniformly excellent conditions produced by succinylcholine. The data suggest that a four-minute priming interval is as effective as a seven-minute interval. The results of this study differed substantially from previous unblinded studies; therefore, it is suggested that a randomized, double-blind design with simultaneous succinylcholine controls be considered a prerequisite for future studies of intubation conditions.
本文报告了一系列关于使用非去极化肌松药预注方案来研究插管条件的对照、随机、双盲试验结果。在研究的第一阶段,各实验组的用药情况如下:A组,筒箭毒碱(DTC)3毫克+琥珀胆碱1.5毫克/千克;B组,阿曲库铵0.05毫克/千克+0.35毫克/千克;C组,维库溴铵0.01毫克/千克+0.07毫克/千克。在第二阶段:D组,未使用肌松药;E组,DTC 0.05毫克/千克+维库溴铵0.07毫克/千克;F组,维库溴铵0.01毫克/千克+维库溴铵0.12毫克/千克。在第三阶段,G组,筒箭毒碱3毫克+琥珀胆碱1.5毫克/千克;H组,维库溴铵0.01毫克/千克+0.09毫克/千克;I组,维库溴铵0.1毫克/千克单次推注。在60秒时评估插管条件。第一阶段和第二阶段采用7分钟的预注间隔,第三阶段采用4分钟的间隔。预注产生的插管条件明显优于同等剂量的单次推注;然而,预注的插管条件似乎比不上琥珀胆碱所产生的始终良好的条件。数据表明,4分钟的预注间隔与7分钟的间隔效果相当。本研究结果与之前的非盲法研究有很大不同;因此,建议将采用琥珀胆碱同步对照的随机双盲设计视为未来插管条件研究的先决条件。