Nagaoka Tomohito, Uzawa Kazuhiro, Seki Yuji, Morales Chocano Daniel
Department of Anatomy, St. Marianna University School of Medicine, Kawasaki, Japan.
Faculty of Human Sciences, University of East Asia, Shimonoseki, Japan.
PLoS One. 2017 Sep 28;12(9):e0185421. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0185421. eCollection 2017.
Pacopampa, a ceremonial complex in Peru's northern highlands, reveals early evidence of trauma in the Middle to Late Formative Period coinciding with the emergence of social stratification in the area. We examine the prevalence of trauma in human remains found at the site and present evidence of the circumstances surrounding the deaths of individuals who lived during the early stages of Andean civilization.
The materials are the remains of 104 individuals (38 non-adult and 66 adult) from the Middle to Late Formative Periods. We explored trauma macroscopically and recorded patterns based on skeletons' locations, age at death, sex, social class, and chronology.
We detected trauma in remains over the Middle to Late Formative Periods. While the prevalence of trauma was minimal in the Middle Formative Period, skeletons from the subsequent era exhibit more severe disturbances. However, all the skeletons show signs of healing and affected individuals experienced a low degree of trauma.
Given the archaeological context (the remains were recovered from sites of ceremonial practices), as well as the equal distribution of trauma among both sexes and a lack of defensive architecture, it is plausible that rituals, rather than organized warfare or raids, caused most of the exhibited trauma. Pacopampa was home to a complex society founded on ritual activity in a ceremonial center: this is indicated by the presence of ritual violence in a society that built impressively large, ceremonial architecture and developed social stratification without any political control of surplus agricultural goods.
帕科潘帕是秘鲁北部高地的一个礼仪建筑群,它揭示了在中晚期形成期创伤的早期证据,这一时期恰逢该地区社会分层的出现。我们研究了在该遗址发现的人类遗骸中创伤的患病率,并提供了围绕安第斯文明早期生活的个体死亡情况的证据。
材料是来自中晚期形成期的104具个体(38具非成年人和66具成年人)的遗骸。我们宏观地探究了创伤情况,并根据骨骼位置、死亡年龄、性别、社会阶层和年代记录了相关模式。
我们在中晚期形成期的遗骸中检测到了创伤。虽然在中期形成期创伤的患病率很低,但随后时期的骨骼显示出更严重的损伤。然而,所有骨骼都有愈合迹象,受影响个体经历的创伤程度较低。
鉴于考古背景(遗骸是从礼仪活动场所发掘出来的),以及两性间创伤分布均等且缺乏防御性建筑,很有可能是仪式而非有组织的战争或袭击导致了所呈现的大部分创伤。帕科潘帕是一个基于礼仪中心的仪式活动建立起来的复杂社会的所在地:这一点由一个建造了令人印象深刻的大型礼仪建筑且发展出社会分层但对剩余农产品没有任何政治管控的社会中存在仪式性暴力所表明。