Tung Tiffiny A
Department of Anthropology, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN 37235, USA.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 2007 Jul;133(3):941-56. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.20565.
This study examines bioarchaeological evidence for violence during the period of Wari imperialism in the Peruvian Andes through analysis of skeletal trauma from three populations dating to AD 650-800. The samples are from contemporaneous archaeological sites: Conchopata, a Wari heartland site in central highland Peru; Beringa, a community of commoners in the Majes valley of the southern Wari hinterland; and La Real, a high status mortuary site, also in the Majes valley. Given the expansionist nature of Wari and its military-related iconography and weaponry, it is hypothesized that Wari imperialism was concomitant with greater levels of violence relative to other prehispanic groups in the Andes. It is also hypothesized that differential articulation with the Wari empire (e.g., heartland vs. hinterland groups) affected the frequency and patterning of trauma. Results show that cranial trauma frequency of the three Wari era samples is significantly greater than several other Andean skeletal populations. This suggests that Wari rule was associated with high levels of violence, though it may not have always been related to militarism. The three adult samples show similar frequencies of cranial trauma (Conchopata = 26%; Beringa = 33%; La Real = 31%). This may suggest that differential positioning in the Wari empire had little effect on exposure to violence. Sex-based differences in cranial trauma frequencies are present only at La Real, but wound patterning differs between the sexes: females display more wounds on the posterior of the cranium, while males show more on the anterior. These data suggest that Wari rule may have contributed to violence.
本研究通过分析公元650 - 800年三个群体的骨骼创伤,考察了秘鲁安第斯山脉瓦里帝国时期暴力行为的生物考古学证据。样本来自同时期的考古遗址:孔乔帕塔,位于秘鲁中部高地的瓦里中心地带遗址;贝林加,位于瓦里帝国南部腹地马耶斯山谷的平民社区;以及同样位于马耶斯山谷的高地位墓葬遗址拉雷亚尔。鉴于瓦里的扩张主义性质及其与军事相关的图像和武器,研究假设瓦里帝国时期相对于安第斯山脉其他前西班牙时期的群体,伴随着更高程度的暴力行为。研究还假设与瓦里帝国的不同联系(例如,中心地带与腹地群体)会影响创伤的频率和模式。结果表明,三个瓦里时代样本的颅骨创伤频率显著高于其他几个安第斯骨骼群体。这表明瓦里统治与高水平的暴力行为有关,尽管这可能并不总是与军国主义相关。三个成年样本显示出相似的颅骨创伤频率(孔乔帕塔 = 26%;贝林加 = 33%;拉雷亚尔 = 31%)。这可能表明在瓦里帝国中的不同定位对遭受暴力的影响不大。颅骨创伤频率的性别差异仅在拉雷亚尔存在,但男女之间的伤口模式不同:女性颅骨后部的伤口更多,而男性前部的伤口更多。这些数据表明瓦里统治可能导致了暴力行为。