Vale Tom A, Symmonds Mkael, Polydefkis Michael, Byrnes Kelly, Rice Andrew S C, Themistocleous Andreas C, Bennett David L H
Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Cutaneous Nerve Laboratory, Neurology, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, USA.
Brain. 2017 Oct 1;140(10):2557-2569. doi: 10.1093/brain/awx215.
Non-freezing cold injury develops after sustained exposure to cold temperatures, resulting in tissue cooling but not freezing. This can result in persistent sensory disturbance of the hands and feet including numbness, paraesthesia and chronic pain. Both vascular and neurological aetiologies of this pain have been suggested but remain unproven. We prospectively approached patients referred for clinical assessment of chronic pain following non-freezing cold injury between 12 February 2014 and 30 November 2016. Of 47 patients approached, 42 consented to undergo detailed neurological evaluations including: questionnaires to detail pain location and characteristics, structured neurological examination, quantitative sensory testing, nerve conduction studies and skin biopsy for intraepidermal nerve fibre assessment. Of the 42 study participants, all had experienced non-freezing cold injury while serving in the UK armed services and the majority were of African descent (76.2%) and male (95.2%). Many participants reported multiple exposures to cold. The median time between initial injury and referral was 3.72 years. Pain was principally localized to the hands and the feet, neuropathic in nature and in all study participants associated with cold hypersensitivity. Clinical examination and quantitative sensory testing were consistent with a sensory neuropathy. In all cases, large fibre nerve conduction studies were normal. The intraepidermal nerve fibre density was markedly reduced with 90.5% of participants having a count at or below the 0.05 centile of published normative controls. Using the Neuropathic Pain Special Interest Group of the International Association for the Study of Pain grading for neuropathic pain, 100% had probable and 95.2% definite neuropathic pain. Chronic non-freezing cold injury is a disabling neuropathic pain disorder due to a sensory neuropathy. Why some individuals develop an acute painful sensory neuropathy on sustained cold exposure is not yet known, but individuals of African descent appear vulnerable. Screening tools, such as the DN4 questionnaire, and treatment algorithms for neuropathic pain should now be used in the management of these patients.
非冻伤性冷损伤是在持续暴露于低温环境后发生的,会导致组织冷却但不会冻伤。这可能会导致手脚出现持续性感觉障碍,包括麻木、感觉异常和慢性疼痛。虽然有人提出这种疼痛的病因涉及血管和神经方面,但仍未得到证实。在2014年2月12日至2016年11月30日期间,我们对因非冻伤性冷损伤后慢性疼痛而前来进行临床评估的患者进行了前瞻性研究。在接触的47名患者中,42名同意接受详细的神经学评估,包括:详细描述疼痛部位和特征的问卷、结构化神经学检查、定量感觉测试、神经传导研究以及用于评估表皮内神经纤维的皮肤活检。在42名研究参与者中,所有人都在英国军队服役期间经历过非冻伤性冷损伤,大多数为非洲裔(76.2%)且为男性(95.2%)。许多参与者报告多次暴露于寒冷环境。初次受伤与转诊之间的中位时间为3.72年。疼痛主要局限于手脚,性质为神经性,并且在所有研究参与者中都与冷超敏反应有关。临床检查和定量感觉测试与感觉神经病变一致。在所有病例中,大纤维神经传导研究均正常。表皮内神经纤维密度显著降低,90.5%的参与者计数处于或低于已发表的正常对照的第0.05百分位数。根据国际疼痛研究协会神经病理性疼痛特别兴趣小组的神经病理性疼痛分级,100%的患者可能患有神经病理性疼痛,95.2%的患者确诊患有神经病理性疼痛。慢性非冻伤性冷损伤是一种由感觉神经病变引起的致残性神经病理性疼痛疾病。为何有些人在持续暴露于寒冷环境后会发展为急性疼痛性感觉神经病变尚不清楚,但非洲裔个体似乎易患此病。现在应将诸如DN4问卷等筛查工具以及神经病理性疼痛的治疗算法用于这些患者的管理。