Matischek-Jauk Marlies, Krammer Georg, Reicher Hannelore
University College of Teacher Education Styria, Ortweinplatz 1, Graz, Austria.
University of Graz, Merangasse 70/2, Graz, Austria.
Health Promot Int. 2018 Dec 1;33(6):1022-1032. doi: 10.1093/heapro/dax050.
This article investigates the importance of implementation level for the effectiveness of the school-based life skills program Lions Quest in a sample of Austrian students (n = 363 from three schools; aged 9-15 at T1). A quasi-experimental pre- and post-test design with intervention and control group over 2 years was used. The effects of low, average, and high implementation levels on the outcome variables classroom climate, bullying and psychosocial health were analyzed. Multilevel analyses of the longitudinal data indicated greatest effects in the intervention group with highest implementation level, smaller effects with average implementation level, and no or rather detrimental effects in one case with the low implementation level (always compared with the control group who received no intervention). A moderate implementation level was necessary to foster the programs aims for three out of four aspects of class climate and bullying, while no effects were found for psychosocial health. These results are discussed with respect to key factors that are important for successful implementation of school programs.
本文以奥地利学生样本(来自三所学校的363名学生;T1阶段年龄在9至15岁)为研究对象,探讨实施水平对校本生活技能项目“狮子探索”有效性的重要性。采用了为期两年的干预组与对照组准实验前后测设计。分析了低、中、高实施水平对课堂氛围、欺凌行为和心理社会健康等结果变量的影响。对纵向数据的多层次分析表明,实施水平最高的干预组效果最佳,中等实施水平的效果较小,低实施水平的一组在一个案例中没有效果或产生了有害影响(始终与未接受干预的对照组相比)。中等实施水平对于促进课堂氛围和欺凌行为四个方面中的三个方面的项目目标是必要的,而在心理社会健康方面未发现有效果。本文结合对学校项目成功实施至关重要的关键因素对这些结果进行了讨论。