Jepson Paul, Arakelyan Irina
School of Geography and the Environment, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford, OX1 3QY, United Kingdom.
Environ Sci Policy. 2017 Oct;76:70-77. doi: 10.1016/j.envsci.2017.06.008.
Tree diseases are on the increase in many countries and the implications of their appearance can be political, as well as ecological and economic. Preventative policy approaches to tree diseases are difficult to formulate because dispersal pathways for pest and pathogens are numerous, poorly known and likely to be beyond human management control. Genomic techniques could offer the quickest and most predictable approach to developing a disease tolerant native ash. The population of European Ash (or) has suffered major losses in the last decade, due to the onset of (previously called ) commonly known in the UK as ash dieback. This study presents evidence on the public acceptability of tree-breed solutions to the spread of , with the main aim to provide science and policy with an up-stream 'steer' on the likely public acceptability of different tree breeding solutions. The findings showed that whilst there was a firm anti-GM and '' attitude among UK publics, there was an equally firm and perhaps slightly larger pragmatic attitude that GM (science and technology) should be used if there is a good reason to do so, for example if it can help protect trees from disease and help feed the world. The latter view was significantly stronger among younger age groups (Millennials), those living in urban areas and when the (GM)modified trees were destined for urban and plantation, rather than countryside settings. Overall, our findings suggest that the UK government could consider genomic solutions to tree breeding with more confidence in the future, as large and influential publics appear to be relaxed about the use of genomic techniques to increase tolerance of trees to disease.
在许多国家,树木疾病正在增加,其出现带来的影响涉及政治、生态和经济等方面。制定针对树木疾病的预防性政策方法很困难,因为害虫和病原体的传播途径众多,鲜为人知,而且可能超出人类管理控制范围。基因组技术可能为培育耐病本土白蜡树提供最快捷、最可预测的方法。在过去十年中,欧洲白蜡树种群遭受了重大损失,这是由于一种疾病(以前称为)的出现,在英国通常被称为白蜡树枯梢病。本研究提供了关于树木育种解决方案对该疾病传播的公众可接受性的证据,主要目的是为科学和政策提供关于不同树木育种解决方案可能的公众可接受性的上游“指导”。研究结果表明,虽然英国公众中存在坚定的反转基因和“反技术”态度,但也存在同样坚定且可能略占上风的务实态度,即如果有充分理由,例如如果它能帮助保护树木免受疾病侵害并养活世界,就应该使用转基因(科学和技术)。后一种观点在年轻群体(千禧一代)、居住在城市地区的人群以及转基因树木用于城市和种植园而非农村环境时更为强烈。总体而言,我们的研究结果表明,英国政府未来可以更有信心地考虑基因组解决方案用于树木育种,因为大量且有影响力的公众似乎对使用基因组技术提高树木抗病能力持宽松态度。