Black D A Jason, Pilcher Christine, Drake Shawn, Maude Erika, Glynn David
Scoliosis SOS Clinic, 63 Mansell Street, London, E1 8AN UK.
Arkansas State University, PO Box 910, Jonesboro, AR 72467 USA.
Scoliosis Spinal Disord. 2017 Sep 27;12:34. doi: 10.1186/s13013-017-0141-z. eCollection 2017.
It has been highlighted in both Poland and the United States of America (USA) that knowledge of idiopathic scoliosis (IS) among physiotherapy students is limited with respect to the 2011 International Society on Scoliosis Orthopaedic and Rehabilitation Treatment (SOSORT) guidelines. Early detection of scoliosis and correct initial management is essential in effective care, and thus physiotherapists should be aware of the basic criteria for diagnosis and indications for treatment. The aim of this study was to evaluate the basic knowledge of IS in physiotherapy students trained in the United Kingdom (UK).
A previously designed and tested 10-question survey, including knowledge of the 2011 SOSORT guidelines, was transcribed onto an online-survey platform. Questions were designed to analyse knowledge of definition, cause, development, prevalence, diagnosis, treatment and bracing of scoliosis. All UK universities offering physiotherapy degrees were invited to participate, with the programme lead of each institution asked to distribute the questionnaire to all penultimate and final year physiotherapy students (bachelor's and master's degrees). The final number of students who received the study invitation is unknown. The survey link closed after 8 weeks of data collection.
Two hundred and six students, split over 12 institutions, successfully completed the questionnaire. Analysis showed that 79% of students recognised when IS is likely to develop, yet only 52% recognised that IS's aetiology is unknown. Eighty-eight percent of students incorrectly defined IS as a 2-dimensional deformity, with only 24% successfully recognising the prevalence of IS within the scoliosis population. Just 12% knew the criteria for diagnosis; however, 93% were unable to recognise the appropriate treatment approach through therapeutic exercise. Finally, 54% of students managed to identify correctly when bracing is recommended for IS. In comparison to previous studies within the USA, students in the UK performed worse in relation to all questions except treatment (7% answered correctly vs 3% in the American study).
With only 7% of students able to answer > 50% of the survey questions correctly, there is a clear lack of knowledge of appropriate IS diagnosis and care which could directly impact the information these patients are given within the first contact primary care in the UK.
在波兰和美利坚合众国(美国)都有人强调,物理治疗专业学生对特发性脊柱侧凸(IS)的了解在2011年国际脊柱侧凸矫形与康复治疗协会(SOSORT)指南方面较为有限。脊柱侧凸的早期检测和正确的初始管理对于有效治疗至关重要,因此物理治疗师应了解诊断的基本标准和治疗指征。本研究的目的是评估在英国接受培训的物理治疗专业学生对IS的基本知识。
一份先前设计并经过测试的包含10个问题的调查问卷,包括对2011年SOSORT指南的了解,被转录到一个在线调查平台上。问题旨在分析对脊柱侧凸的定义、病因、发展、患病率、诊断、治疗和支具治疗的了解。所有提供物理治疗学位的英国大学都被邀请参与,每个机构的项目负责人被要求将问卷分发给所有本科和硕士最后一年及倒数第二年的物理治疗专业学生。收到研究邀请的学生最终数量未知。数据收集8周后调查链接关闭。
来自12所机构的206名学生成功完成了问卷。分析表明,79%的学生知道IS可能在何时发展,但只有52%的学生认识到IS的病因不明。88%的学生将IS错误地定义为二维畸形,只有24%的学生成功认识到IS在脊柱侧凸人群中的患病率。只有12%的学生知道诊断标准;然而,93%的学生无法通过治疗性运动识别出合适的治疗方法。最后,54%的学生能够正确识别何时建议对IS进行支具治疗。与美国之前的研究相比,英国学生在除治疗外的所有问题上表现更差(7%回答正确,而美国研究中为3%)。
只有7%的学生能够正确回答超过50%的调查问卷问题,显然缺乏对IS适当诊断和护理的知识,这可能直接影响在英国初级医疗首次接触中给予这些患者的信息。