Department of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Division of Pharmacy, School of Medicine, University of Tasmania, Hobart, Australia.
J Physiol. 2018 Jan 15;596(2):231-252. doi: 10.1113/JP274970. Epub 2017 Nov 12.
While several studies have investigated the effects of exercise training in human skeletal muscle and the chronic effect of β -agonist treatment in rodent muscle, their effects on muscle proteome signature with related functional measures in humans are still incompletely understood. Herein we show that daily β -agonist treatment attenuates training-induced enhancements in exercise performance and maximal oxygen consumption, and alters muscle proteome signature and phenotype in trained young men. Daily β -agonist treatment abolished several of the training-induced enhancements in muscle oxidative capacity and caused a repression of muscle metabolic pathways; furthermore, β -agonist treatment induced a slow-to-fast twitch muscle phenotype transition. The present study indicates that chronic β -agonist treatment confounds the positive effect of high intensity training on exercise performance and oxidative capacity, which is of interest for the large proportion of persons using inhaled β -agonists on a daily basis, including athletes.
Although the effects of training have been studied for decades, data on muscle proteome signature remodelling induced by high intensity training in relation to functional changes in humans remains incomplete. Likewise, β -agonists are frequently used to counteract exercise-induced bronchoconstriction, but the effects β -agonist treatment on muscle remodelling and adaptations to training are unknown. In a placebo-controlled parallel study, we randomly assigned 21 trained men to 4 weeks of high intensity training with (HIT+β A) or without (HIT) daily inhalation of β -agonist (terbutaline, 4 mg dose ). Of 486 proteins identified by mass-spectrometry proteomics of muscle biopsies sampled before and after the intervention, 32 and 85 were changing (false discovery rate (FDR) ≤5%) with the intervention in HIT and HIT+β A, respectively. Proteome signature changes were different in HIT and HIT+β A (P = 0.005), wherein β -agonist caused a repression of 25 proteins in HIT+β A compared to HIT, and an upregulation of 7 proteins compared to HIT. β -Agonist repressed or even downregulated training-induced enrichment of pathways related to oxidative phosphorylation and glycogen metabolism, but upregulated pathways related to histone trimethylation and the nucleosome. Muscle contractile phenotype changed differently in HIT and HIT+β A (P ≤ 0.001), with a fast-to-slow twitch transition in HIT and a slow-to-fast twitch transition in HIT+β A. β -Agonist attenuated training-induced enhancements in maximal oxygen consumption (P ≤ 0.01) and exercise performance (6.1 vs. 11.6%, P ≤ 0.05) in HIT+β A compared to HIT. These findings indicate that daily β -agonist treatment attenuates the beneficial effects of high intensity training on exercise performance and oxidative capacity, and causes remodelling of muscle proteome signature towards a fast-twitch phenotype.
虽然已有几项研究调查了运动训练对人类骨骼肌的影响,以及β-激动剂在啮齿动物肌肉中的慢性作用,但β-激动剂治疗对人类肌肉蛋白质组特征及其相关功能测量的影响仍不完全清楚。本文显示,β-激动剂的每日治疗减弱了训练引起的运动表现和最大耗氧量的增强,并改变了训练年轻男性的肌肉蛋白质组特征和表型。β-激动剂的每日治疗消除了肌肉氧化能力增强的几种训练诱导的增强作用,并抑制了肌肉代谢途径;此外,β-激动剂治疗引起慢肌向快肌表型的转变。本研究表明,慢性β-激动剂治疗会干扰高强度训练对运动表现和氧化能力的积极影响,这对于包括运动员在内的大量每日使用吸入性β-激动剂的人来说是非常重要的。
虽然训练的效果已经研究了几十年,但关于高强度训练引起的肌肉蛋白质组特征重塑与人类功能变化的相关数据仍然不完整。同样,β-激动剂常用于对抗运动引起的支气管收缩,但β-激动剂治疗对肌肉重塑和适应训练的影响尚不清楚。在一项安慰剂对照的平行研究中,我们随机分配 21 名训练有素的男性接受 4 周的高强度训练,其中(HIT+β A)或不接受(HIT)β-激动剂(特布他林,4mg 剂量)的每日吸入。通过对干预前后肌肉活检样本进行质谱蛋白质组学分析,鉴定出 486 种蛋白质,其中 32 种和 85 种(错误发现率(FDR)≤5%)在 HIT 和 HIT+β A 中发生变化。HIT 和 HIT+β A 中的蛋白质组特征变化不同(P=0.005),其中β-激动剂在 HIT+β A 中引起 25 种蛋白质的抑制,而在 HIT 中引起 7 种蛋白质的上调。β-激动剂抑制甚至下调了与氧化磷酸化和糖原代谢相关的途径的训练诱导的富集,但上调了与组蛋白三甲基化和核小体相关的途径。HIT 和 HIT+β A 中的肌肉收缩表型变化不同(P≤0.001),HIT 中发生快肌向慢肌的转变,HIT+β A 中发生慢肌向快肌的转变。β-激动剂减弱了 HIT+β A 中训练引起的最大耗氧量(P≤0.01)和运动表现(6.1%对 11.6%,P≤0.05)的增强。这些发现表明,β-激动剂的每日治疗减弱了高强度训练对运动表现和氧化能力的有益影响,并导致肌肉蛋白质组特征向快肌表型的重塑。