Newsom S W, Rowland C
Papworth Hospital, Cambridge, UK.
J Hosp Infect. 1988 Apr;11 Suppl B:21-6. doi: 10.1016/0195-6701(88)90152-1.
Chlorhexidine in spirit is used to reduce the skin bacterial load before surgery; and recently prewashing with chlorhexidine scrub has been advocated. We describe three studies on cardio-thoracic surgical patients--particularly those having coronary artery grafts with long leg and sternal wounds. Two studies compared prewashes with chlorhexidine scrub (Hibiscrub-ICI) or soap. Study Number One (250 patients per group) was of wound infections; and Number Two (25 patients per group) was of alterations in skin flora for 10 days postoperation. Chlorhexidine scrub failed to reduce overall wound infection rates in Study 1, although leg wounds healed more quickly with less inflammation. Study Two showed that the scrub had a significant effect on skin flora that lasted at least 3 days postoperation. Study Number Three was of 100 patients (no chlorhexidine scrub) examined for methicillin-resistant coagulase-negative staphylococci (MRSE) by cultures of swabs from the leg, sternum and chest drain site before and after operation on methicillin agar. Three per cent of patients had MRSE preoperation (1 doctor) and 23% postoperation. One thousand strains were tested by agar dilution against methicillin and chlorhexidine. MRSE had a 2-8-fold increased resistance to chlorhexidine compared to a greater than 256-fold to methicillin. Thus although chlorhexidine has a marked persistent effect on skin flora, emergence of major resistance is unlikely. Use of postoperative chlorhexidine should be investigated further.
术前使用酒精洗必泰以降低皮肤细菌载量;最近有人主张用洗必泰擦洗液进行术前清洗。我们描述了三项针对心胸外科手术患者的研究——尤其是那些进行长腿冠状动脉搭桥术和胸骨伤口手术的患者。两项研究比较了用洗必泰擦洗液(洗必泰擦洗液-ICI)或肥皂进行术前清洗的效果。第一项研究(每组250名患者)针对伤口感染;第二项研究(每组25名患者)针对术后10天皮肤菌群的变化。在第一项研究中,洗必泰擦洗液未能降低总体伤口感染率,尽管腿部伤口愈合更快,炎症更少。第二项研究表明,擦洗液对皮肤菌群有显著影响,这种影响在术后至少持续3天。第三项研究对100名患者(未使用洗必泰擦洗液)进行了研究,通过在甲氧西林琼脂上培养腿部、胸骨和胸腔引流部位的拭子,检测术前和术后耐甲氧西林凝固酶阴性葡萄球菌(MRSE)。3%的患者术前有MRSE(1名医生检测),术后为23%。用琼脂稀释法对1000株菌株进行了甲氧西林和洗必泰耐药性检测。与对甲氧西林的耐药性增加超过256倍相比,MRSE对洗必泰的耐药性增加了2至8倍。因此,尽管洗必泰对皮肤菌群有显著的持续影响,但不太可能出现主要耐药性。术后使用洗必泰的情况应进一步研究。