Pattanarattanamolee Ratrawee, Lertsinudom Somkid, Nakahara Shinji, Sakamoto Tetsuya
Trauma and Critical Care Center, Khon Kaen Regional Hospital, Khon Kaen, Thailand.
Department of Emergency Medicine, Teikyo University School of Medicine, Itabashi, Tokyo, Japan.
J Emerg Med. 2017 Nov;53(5):730-734. doi: 10.1016/j.jemermed.2017.08.017. Epub 2017 Oct 5.
Ambulance crashes delay patient transfer and endanger patients, ambulance crews, and other road users. In low- and middle-income countries, where motor vehicle crash rates are typically high, ambulances have a high risk of being involved in a crash. This case report describes an ambulance crash in Thailand to elucidate modifiable problems in current protocols and practices of emergency medical services.
In November 2016, a 28-year-old male driver of an ambulance died in a crash while transferring a female patient with dizziness to a rural hospital. The driver and another ambulance crew member were sitting in the front seats unrestrained. The other occupants were in the patient compartment unrestrained. The driver was driving the ambulance within the speed limit. He made a sharp turn trying to evade a dog, and the ambulance crashed head-on into a roadside tree. The cabin sustained severe damage, and the occupants in the patient compartment were struck against the compartment wall and were struck by unsecured equipment and the stretcher. The driver sustained a severe brain injury. The other occupants, including the female patient, sustained minor injuries. WHY SHOULD AN EMERGENCY PHYSICIAN BE AWARE OF THIS?: This case raises safety issues concerning the following aspects of ambulance operations in low- and middle-income countries: speed limit, safety device use, seatbelt use, securing equipment, and vehicle safety standards. Systematic measures to change protocols or even legislation, as well as data collection, are required to address these issues.
救护车撞车事故会延误患者转运,并危及患者、救护人员及其他道路使用者的安全。在机动车撞车率通常较高的低收入和中等收入国家,救护车发生撞车事故的风险很高。本病例报告描述了泰国发生的一起救护车撞车事故,以阐明当前紧急医疗服务协议和实践中可改进的问题。
2016年11月,一名28岁的男性救护车司机在将一名头晕的女性患者转运至乡村医院途中死于撞车事故。司机和另一名救护人员坐在前排座位上,未系安全带。其他乘客在患者车厢内,也未系安全带。司机在限速范围内驾驶救护车。他急转弯试图躲避一只狗,结果救护车迎面撞上了路边的一棵树。车厢严重受损,患者车厢内的乘客撞到了车厢壁,并被未固定的设备和担架击中。司机脑部受重伤。其他乘客,包括那名女性患者,受了轻伤。
急诊医生为何应了解此事?:本病例引发了低收入和中等收入国家救护车运营以下方面的安全问题:限速、安全装置使用、安全带使用、设备固定和车辆安全标准。需要采取系统性措施来改变协议甚至立法,并进行数据收集,以解决这些问题。