Houlton T M R, Billings B K
Human Variation and Identification Research Unit, School of Anatomical Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, 7 York Road, Parktown, Johannesburg, Gauteng 2193, South Africa.
Human Variation and Identification Research Unit, School of Anatomical Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, 7 York Road, Parktown, Johannesburg, Gauteng 2193, South Africa.
Homo. 2017 Oct;68(5):362-377. doi: 10.1016/j.jchb.2017.08.004. Epub 2017 Sep 14.
This paper addresses the history, composition and scientific value of one of the most comprehensive facemask collections in Africa, the Raymond A. Dart Collection of African Life and Death Masks. Housed within the School of Anatomical Sciences at the University of the Witwatersrand (South Africa), it comprises 1110 masks (397 life, 487 death, 226 unknown). Life masks represent populations throughout Africa; death masks predominately southern Africa. Males preponderate by 75%. Recorded ages are error prone, but suggest most life masks are those of <35 year-olds, death masks of 36+ year-olds. A total of 241 masks have associated skeletons, 209 presenting a complete skull. Life masks date between 1927 and c.1980s, death masks 1933 and 1963. This historical collection presents uncanny associations with outmoded typological and evolutionary theories. Once perceived an essential scientific resource, performed craniofacial superimpositions identify the nose as the only stable feature maintained, with the remaining face best preserved in young individuals with minimal body fat. The facemask collection is most viable for teaching and research within the history of science, specifically physical anthropology, and presents some value to craniofacial identification. Future research will have to be conducted with appropriate ethical considerations to science and medicine.
本文探讨了非洲最全面的面罩收藏之一——雷蒙德·A·达特非洲生死面罩收藏的历史、构成和科学价值。该收藏存于南非金山大学解剖科学学院,包含1110个面罩(397个生前面罩、487个死后面罩、226个情况不明的面罩)。生前面罩代表了非洲各地的人群;死后面罩主要来自南部非洲。男性面罩占比75%。记录的年龄容易出错,但表明大多数生前面罩是35岁以下人群的,死后面罩是36岁及以上人群的。共有241个面罩与骨骼相关联,其中209个配有完整头骨。生前面罩的年代在1927年至约20世纪80年代之间,死后面罩的年代在1933年至1963年之间。这个历史收藏与过时的类型学和进化理论有着密切联系。曾经被视为重要科学资源的颅面叠加研究表明,鼻子是唯一保持稳定的特征,而面部其他部分在体脂最少的年轻人中保存得最好。该面罩收藏在科学史,特别是体质人类学的教学和研究中最具可行性,对颅面识别也有一定价值。未来的研究必须在科学和医学的适当伦理考量下进行。