AlRuthia Yazed Sulaiman, AlKofide Hadeel, AlAjmi Refaa'h, Balkhi Bander, Alghamdi Ahmed, AlNasser Albandari, Alayed Areej, Alshammari Maali, Alsuhaibani Danah, Alathbah Asma
Correspondence: Dr. Yazed Sulaiman AlRuthia Department of Clnical Pharmacy, King Saud University, P.O. Box 2454, Riyadh, 11451, Saudi Arabia
Ann Saudi Med. 2017 Sep-Oct;37(5):375-385. doi: 10.5144/0256-4947.2017.375.
Drug shortages are a serious and complex issue in any healthcare system. We conducted this study because the prevalence of drug shortages in Saudi Arabia is largely unknown, while there have been reports of shortages.
To explore the prevalence and characteristics of drug shortages as well as identify strategies to minimize their impact on patient care and safety in large hospitals.
Questionnaire-based cross-sectional study.
Pharmacy departments in secondary and tertiary care hospitals in the city of Riyadh.
Pharmacists in ten hospitals, categorized as Ministry of Health [MOH], MOH-affiliated medical cities, and non-MOH, were recruited using convenience sampling. The European Association of Hospital Pharmacists drug shortage questionnaire was administered to survey pharmacists about drug shortages in their hospitals.
Percentages of drug class shortages, characteristics, and strategies to minimize impact on patient care and safety across each hospital sector.
Of 200 pharmacists invited to participate, 120 pharmacists completed the questionnaire (60% response rate). Twenty-four percent were from MOH hospitals, 32% from MOH-affiliated medical cities, and 44% from non-MOH hospitals. A significantly higher percentage of pharmacists from MOH-affiliated medical cities (42.11%) reported encountering drug shortages on a daily basis compared to 13.79% and 15.09% of participants from MOH-hospitals and non-MOH hospitals, respectively (P=.001). The top three drug classes that >= 25% of participants reported having shortages of were cardiovascular, antineoplastic, and endocrine drugs. The two most common strategies that were reported to minimize the impact of drug shortages on patient care by more than 70% of participants were informing prescribers and recommending alternative drugs, and alerting hospital staff about the presence of drug shortages using new communication tools.
The relatively high reported rates of drug shortages in some hospitals should encourage health policymakers to address this serious public health problem.
The generazibility of the study's findings were limited by the small sample size, convenience sampling technique, self-reported data, and the fact that only pharmacists were invited to participate.
药品短缺在任何医疗体系中都是一个严重且复杂的问题。我们开展这项研究是因为沙特阿拉伯药品短缺的普遍程度很大程度上未知,尽管已有短缺情况的报告。
探讨药品短缺的普遍程度和特征,并确定在大型医院中将其对患者护理和安全的影响降至最低的策略。
基于问卷的横断面研究。
利雅得市二级和三级护理医院的药房。
采用便利抽样法招募了十家医院的药剂师,这些医院分为卫生部(MOH)医院、卫生部附属医疗城医院和非卫生部医院。使用欧洲医院药剂师协会药品短缺问卷对药剂师进行调查,了解其所在医院的药品短缺情况。
各医院部门药品类别短缺的百分比、特征以及将对患者护理和安全的影响降至最低的策略。
在受邀参与的200名药剂师中,120名药剂师完成了问卷(回复率为60%)。24%来自卫生部医院,32%来自卫生部附属医疗城医院,44%来自非卫生部医院。与卫生部医院(13.79%)和非卫生部医院(15.09%)的参与者相比,卫生部附属医疗城医院的药剂师中每天遇到药品短缺的比例显著更高(42.11%)(P = 0.001)。超过25%的参与者报告短缺的前三类药品是心血管药物、抗肿瘤药物和内分泌药物。超过70%的参与者报告的将药品短缺对患者护理的影响降至最低的两种最常见策略是告知开处方者并推荐替代药物,以及使用新的沟通工具向医院工作人员通报药品短缺情况。
一些医院报告的相对较高的药品短缺率应促使卫生政策制定者解决这一严重的公共卫生问题。
本研究结果的可推广性受到样本量小、便利抽样技术、自我报告数据以及仅邀请药剂师参与这一事实的限制。