Davies L R, Neve P
School of Life Sciences University of Warwick Wellesbourne UK.
Agroecology Department Rothamsted Research Harpenden Hertfordshire UK.
Weed Res. 2017 Oct;57(5):323-332. doi: 10.1111/wre.12264. Epub 2017 Aug 10.
Glyphosate use in the United Kingdom has more than doubled in the last 20 years. Much of this increase is driven by efforts to control herbicide resistant weeds, particularly , prior to crop drilling. There is precedent for evolution of glyphosate resistance in similar situations, raising concerns over the sustainability of glyphosate use in the UK. We used dose-response experiments to examine variation in glyphosate sensitivity amongst 40 field-collected populations. No populations were resistant to glyphosate, but ED values ranged between 354 and 610 g a.i. ha. Five populations had ED values significantly higher than the unexposed control population collected from a site at Rothamsted Research with no previous glyphosate exposure. Recurrent selection experiments were performed to determine whether variation in glyphosate sensitivity had a heritable basis. Following two rounds of selection, five of six field populations evolved significantly reduced sensitivity to glyphosate, with R/S ratios, based on estimated ED values, ranging from 1.2 to 1.5. These results confirm that there is a heritable basis to variation in glyphosate sensitivity. The response to selection was modest. Evolved populations were not highly resistant to glyphosate, although some twice-selected individuals survived recommended field rates. These results do not represent definitive proof of the potential of to evolve glyphosate resistance, although they do indicate caution is needed when considering the sustainability of increased glyphosate use to control this herbicide resistance-prone species.
在过去20年里,英国草甘膦的使用量增加了一倍多。这种增长很大程度上是由于控制抗除草剂杂草的努力,特别是在作物播种前。在类似情况下有草甘膦抗性进化的先例,这引发了对英国草甘膦使用可持续性的担忧。我们通过剂量反应实验来研究40个田间采集种群对草甘膦敏感性的差异。没有种群对草甘膦具有抗性,但有效剂量(ED)值在354至610克活性成分/公顷之间。有五个种群的ED值显著高于从洛桑试验站一个此前未接触过草甘膦的地点采集的未接触对照种群。进行了轮回选择实验,以确定草甘膦敏感性的差异是否具有遗传基础。经过两轮选择后,六个田间种群中有五个对草甘膦的敏感性显著降低,基于估计的ED值,抗性/敏感性(R/S)比在1.2至1.5之间。这些结果证实了草甘膦敏感性差异存在遗传基础。对选择的反应较为适度。尽管一些经过两次选择的个体在推荐的田间施用量下存活了下来,但进化后的种群对草甘膦并没有高度抗性。这些结果并不代表草甘膦抗性进化可能性的确切证据,尽管它们确实表明在考虑增加草甘膦使用以控制这种易产生除草剂抗性的物种的可持续性时需要谨慎。