Shergill Ravi, Kaka Hussam, Kennedy Sean A, Baerlocher Mark O
Department of Radiology, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Diagn Interv Radiol. 2017 Oct 6;23(6):435-440. doi: 10.5152/dir.2017.16499.
We aimed to determine the publication rate and factors predictive of publication of oral presentations at the annual meetings of the Cardiovascular and Interventional Radiology Society of Europe (CIRSE) and the Society of Interventional Radiology (SIR).
Keywords and authors from oral presentation abstracts at the 2012 CIRSE and SIR annual meetings were used to search PubMed and GoogleScholar for subsequent publication. Logistic regression was performed to identify whether number of authors, country of origin, subject category, methodology, study type, and/or study results were predictive of publication.
A total of 421 abstracts (CIRSE-126, SIR-295) met the inclusion criteria. The overall publication rate across both conferences was 44.9%. Time from conference presentation to publication was 15±8.9 months for CIRSE and 16.3±8.8 months for SIR (P > 0.05), with a combined time interval of 15.9±8.8 months for both. The median impact factor of published abstracts was 2.075 (interquartile range, 2.075-2.775) for CIRSE and 2.093 (2.075-2.856) for SIR (P > 0.05). The most common country of origin for published abstracts was Germany (27.1%) at CIRSE and the United States (69%) at SIR. Logistic regression did not identify factors that were predictive of future publication.
Publication rates were similar for CIRSE and SIR. Factors such as country of origin, topic of study and study results were not predictive of future publication. Authors should not be discouraged from submitting their work to journals based on these factors.
我们旨在确定在欧洲心血管与介入放射学会(CIRSE)和介入放射学会(SIR)年会上口头报告的发表率及发表的预测因素。
使用2012年CIRSE和SIR年会口头报告摘要中的关键词和作者,在PubMed和GoogleScholar上搜索后续发表情况。进行逻辑回归分析以确定作者数量、来源国、主题类别、方法、研究类型和/或研究结果是否为发表的预测因素。
共有421篇摘要(CIRSE - 126篇,SIR - 295篇)符合纳入标准。两个会议的总体发表率为44.9%。CIRSE从会议报告到发表的时间为15±8.9个月,SIR为16.3±8.8个月(P>0.05),两者合并时间间隔为15.9±8.8个月。发表摘要的中位影响因子,CIRSE为2.075(四分位间距,2.075 - 2.775),SIR为2.093(2.075 - 2.856)(P>0.05)。发表摘要最常见的来源国,CIRSE是德国(27.1%),SIR是美国(69%)。逻辑回归未确定可预测未来发表的因素。
CIRSE和SIR的发表率相似。来源国、研究主题和研究结果等因素不能预测未来发表情况。作者不应因这些因素而气馁,不敢将其作品提交给期刊。