Rapid Communication: Evaluation of methane inhibitor 3-nitrooxypropanol and monensin in a high-grain diet using the rumen simulation technique (Rusitec).

The objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of 3-nitrooxypropanol (NOP), a known methane (CH) inhibitor; the ionophore monensin (MON); and their combination on in vitro CH production in a high-grain diet (85% barley grain, 10% barley silage, and 5% vitamin-mineral supplement; DM basis) using a rumen simulation technique (Rusitec). Sixteen fermentation vessels in 2 Rusitec apparatuses (blocks) were used in a completely randomized block design with 4 treatments: Control, NOP (200 µg/g DM), MON (200 µg/g DM), and the combination of 200 µg NOP/g DM and 200 µg MON/g DM (NOP + MON). Two fermenters within each apparatus were randomly assigned to a treatment. Treatments were mixed with 10 g of substrate and supplied on a daily basis. The study included an 8-d adaptation period without treatment supplementation and a 6-d period for addition of treatments. Dry matter disappearance, pH, and total VFA were not affected by treatment ( ≥ 0.34). Acetate proportion was decreased by 8.3% and 14.9% with NOP and NOP + MON ( < 0.01), respectively; however, propionate proportion was not affected by treatment ( = 0.44). The acetate to propionate ratio was lowered by 21.1% with the combination of NOP and MON ( = 0.02), whereas ammonia-N concentration was not affected by treatment ( = 0.50). Total gas production was unaffected ( = 0.50), but CH production decreased by 77.7% and 75.95% ( < 0.01) with NOP and NOP + MON addition, respectively. Concurrently, H gas production increased by 131.3% and 185.6% ( = 0.01) with NOP and NOP + MON treatments, respectively. The copy number of methanogens was decreased in both solid and liquid phases ( < 0.01) with NOP and NOP + MON treatments. Despite the combination of NOP + MON showing the greatest decrease in acetate molar proportion and acetate to propionate ratio, it did not further inhibit CH beyond the effect of NOP alone. The decrease in CH emissions with treatments that included NOP occurred along with a decrease in the copy number of methanogens associated with the solid and liquid phases, confirming the inhibitory effects of NOP on these microorganisms. In conclusion, the combined effects of NOP and MON on CH mitigation did not exceed the effect of NOP alone when using a high-grain diet in vitro.