Kamau Anthony, Mung'ayi Vitalis, Yonga Gerald
Department of Anaesthesia, Aga Khan University, East Africa, Nairobi, Kenya.
Department of Internal Medicine, Aga Khan University, East Africa, Nairobi, Kenya.
Afr Health Sci. 2017 Mar;17(1):138-146. doi: 10.4314/ahs.v17i1.18.
Preoperative anxiety is a common perioperative complication seen in approximately 11-80% of adults undergoing surgery. One of the goals of the preanaesthesia clinic is to allay anxiety. A preanaesthesia clinic evaluation has been shown to reduce anxiety however current studies on anxiety and the preanaesthesia clinic have not quantified this reduction.
To determine the reduction in anxiety in patients evaluated in the clinic versus those evaluated in the ward.
Fifty one adult patients with 28 patients in anaesthesia clinic (AC) group and 23 in the ward (W) group were sequentially recruited from both the surgical, gynaecology and antenatal outpatient clinics and the wards. The patient's State Trait Anxiety Index (STAI) was taken once the patient was booked for theatre. The patients then had a preanaesthesia evaluation either in the preanaesthesia outpatient clinic (PAC) or in the wards. Another STAI score was taken in the preoperative area in theatre on the day of surgery. The difference in the change of STAI scores in both groups was then analysed.
Fifty one adult patients were recruited with 28 in the AC group and 23 in the W group. The majority of patients were female (n=38). Statistically significant difference was seen in the reduction of the anxiety scores between the clinic group 2.143 (C.I=1.384-2.902) and ward group 0.74(C.I=0.17-1.31) with a p value=0.0051.There was also significant difference in reduction in anxiety scores within ward group in the patients with no prior anaesthetic experience having a greater reduction than those with prior anaesthetic experience. There were no other significant differences between the two groups.
Patients evaluated in the anaesthesia clinic had a greater reduction in their anxiety but it was not as much as hypothesised which may be due to the multi-factorial nature of preoperative anxiety. A larger multicenter study is recommended to increase generalizability to the population.
术前焦虑是一种常见的围手术期并发症,在接受手术的成年人中,约11%-80%会出现。麻醉前门诊的目标之一是减轻焦虑。麻醉前门诊评估已被证明可减轻焦虑,但目前关于焦虑与麻醉前门诊的研究尚未对这种减轻程度进行量化。
确定在门诊接受评估的患者与在病房接受评估的患者相比,焦虑减轻的情况。
从外科、妇科和产前门诊以及病房连续招募了51名成年患者,其中28名患者进入麻醉门诊(AC)组,23名患者进入病房(W)组。患者一旦被安排手术,即进行状态-特质焦虑量表(STAI)测评。然后,患者在麻醉前门诊(PAC)或病房接受麻醉前评估。手术当天在手术室的术前区域再次进行STAI评分。随后分析两组STAI评分变化的差异。
共招募了51名成年患者,AC组28名,W组23名。大多数患者为女性(n=38)。门诊组焦虑评分降低2.143(置信区间=1.384-2.902),病房组降低0.74(置信区间=0.17-1.31),差异有统计学意义,p值=0.0051。在病房组中,无麻醉经验的患者焦虑评分降低幅度大于有麻醉经验的患者,差异也有统计学意义。两组之间没有其他显著差异。
在麻醉门诊接受评估的患者焦虑减轻程度更大,但未达到预期,这可能是由于术前焦虑的多因素性质所致。建议开展更大规模的多中心研究,以提高研究结果对总体人群的适用性。