T. Denny Sanford School of Social and Family Dynamics, Arizona State University, 850 South Cady Mall, Tempe, AZ 85281, USA.
Department of Human Development & Family Studies, The University of Alabama, 226 Child Development Research Center, Tuscaloosa, AL 35487, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2017 Nov;193:90-100. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2017.09.042. Epub 2017 Sep 27.
Although the relation between stress and physiology is well documented, attempts at understanding the link between racial discrimination and cortisol output, specifically, have produced mixed results, likely due to study characteristics such as racial/ethnic composition of the samples (e.g., African American, Latino), measures of discrimination, and research design (e.g., cross-sectional, experimental).
To estimate the overall association between racial discrimination and cortisol output among racial/ethnic minority individuals and to determine if the association between racial discrimination and cortisol output is moderated by age, race/ethnicity, type of discrimination measure, sex, and research design.
Using a random effects model, the overall effect size based on k = 16 studies (19% unpublished) and N = 1506 participants was r¯ = 0.040, 95% CI = -0.038 to 0.117. Studies were conducted predominantly in the U.S. (81%). Notably, experimental studies (r¯ = 0.267) exhibited larger effect sizes compared to non-experimental studies (r¯ = -0.007). Age, race/ethnicity, type of discrimination measure, and sex did not moderate the effect sizes.
This meta-analysis provides evidence that the measurement of the association between racial discrimination and cortisol is complex, and it offers valuable insight regarding methods and designs that can inform future research on this topic. Limitations and future directions are discussed.
尽管压力与生理之间的关系已有充分记录,但试图理解种族歧视与皮质醇分泌之间的联系的尝试产生了混杂的结果,这可能是由于研究特征(例如,样本的种族/民族构成(例如,非裔美国人,拉丁裔),歧视措施和研究设计(例如,横断面,实验)。
估计种族/少数民族个体中种族歧视与皮质醇分泌之间的总体关联,并确定种族歧视与皮质醇分泌之间的关联是否受年龄,种族/民族,歧视测量类型,性别和研究设计的调节。
使用随机效应模型,基于 k = 16 项研究(19%未发表)和 N = 1506 名参与者的总体效应大小为 r¯ = 0.040,95%CI = -0.038 至 0.117。这些研究主要在美国(81%)进行。值得注意的是,与非实验研究(r¯ = -0.007)相比,实验研究(r¯ = 0.267)的效应大小更大。年龄,种族/民族,歧视测量类型和性别并未调节效应大小。
这项荟萃分析提供了证据表明,种族歧视与皮质醇之间关联的测量是复杂的,并且为该主题的未来研究提供了有关方法和设计的有价值的见解。讨论了局限性和未来方向。