Peirson B R Erick, Bottino Erin, Damerow Julia L, Laubichler Manfred D
ASU-SFI Center for Biosocial Complex Systems, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ, 85287-4501, USA.
arXiv, Cornell University Library, Cornell University, 161 Ho Plaza, Ithaca, NY, 14853, USA.
J Hist Biol. 2017 Nov;50(4):695-751. doi: 10.1007/s10739-017-9499-2.
Journal of the History of Biology provides a fifty-year long record for examining the evolution of the history of biology as a scholarly discipline. In this paper, we present a new dataset and preliminary quantitative analysis of the thematic content of JHB from the perspectives of geography, organisms, and thematic fields. The geographic diversity of authors whose work appears in JHB has increased steadily since 1968, but the geographic coverage of the content of JHB articles remains strongly lopsided toward the United States, United Kingdom, and western Europe and has diversified much less dramatically over time. The taxonomic diversity of organisms discussed in JHB increased steadily between 1968 and the late 1990s but declined in later years, mirroring broader patterns of diversification previously reported in the biomedical research literature. Finally, we used a combination of topic modeling and nonlinear dimensionality reduction techniques to develop a model of multi-article fields within JHB. We found evidence for directional changes in the representation of fields on multiple scales. The diversity of JHB with regard to the representation of thematic fields has increased overall, with most of that diversification occurring in recent years. Drawing on the dataset generated in the course of this analysis, as well as web services in the emerging digital history and philosophy of science ecosystem, we have developed an interactive web platform for exploring the content of JHB, and we provide a brief overview of the platform in this article. As a whole, the data and analyses presented here provide a starting-place for further critical reflection on the evolution of the history of biology over the past half-century.
《生物学史杂志》提供了长达五十年的记录,用于考察生物学史作为一门学术学科的发展演变。在本文中,我们从地理、生物和主题领域的角度,呈现了一个关于《生物学史杂志》主题内容的新数据集及初步定量分析。自1968年以来,发表在《生物学史杂志》上的作者的地理多样性稳步增加,但该杂志文章内容的地理覆盖范围仍严重偏向美国、英国和西欧,且随着时间推移,其多样化程度的变化并不显著。1968年至20世纪90年代末,《生物学史杂志》中讨论的生物分类多样性稳步增加,但在随后几年有所下降,这反映了此前生物医学研究文献中报道的更广泛的多样化模式。最后,我们结合主题建模和非线性降维技术,构建了一个关于《生物学史杂志》内多篇文章领域的模型。我们发现了多个尺度上领域代表性的方向性变化的证据。《生物学史杂志》在主题领域代表性方面的多样性总体上有所增加,其中大部分多样化是在近年来发生的。基于本次分析过程中生成的数据集,以及新兴的数字科学史和科学哲学生态系统中的网络服务,我们开发了一个用于探索《生物学史杂志》内容的交互式网络平台,并在本文中对该平台进行简要概述。总体而言,本文所呈现的数据和分析为进一步批判性反思过去半个世纪生物学史的演变提供了一个起点。