Baig Mirza Tasawer, Sial Ali Akbar, Huma Ambreen, Ahmed Maryam, Shahid Uzma, Syed Nayel
Faculty of Pharmacy, Ziauddin University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Faculty of Medicine, Ziauddin University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Pak J Pharm Sci. 2017 Jul;30(4(Suppl.)):1483-1489.
This study assessed the prescribing pattern of irrational use of antibiotic among children under age of 12 years in public and private sector hospitals in Pakistan. The prospective clinical evaluation of drug utilization pattern of antimicrobials from Patient Bedside File (PBF) of in-patients and Culture Sensitivity Test (CST) reports were evaluated to determine the antibiotic resistance. Two indicators recorded to assess antibiotic prescribing were; dose of prescribed antibiotic (low-dose, rational and high -dose) and Indication (valid or invalid). Antibiotics resistance for 25 selected antibiotics was determined by culture sensitivity test. This study showed that in Private Sector Hospital 77.7% neonates, 13.3% infants and 9% children admitted in ICU were receiving antibiotics, among them only 57.3% neonates, 62% infants and 59.9% children were found valid that is prescribed antibiotics for right indication. 27% neonates, 19% infants and 22.1% children were prescribed under dose of antibiotics, which may lead to antimicrobial resistance and increased cost of hospital stay. Only 29.1% neonates, 30% infants and 36.8% children were receiving rational dosing. In Public Sector Hospital, 65.6% neonates, 19.4% infants and 15% children were receiving antibiotics. Among them valid indication was found in 35.3% neonates, 35.6% infants and 39.8% in children. 33.3% neonates, 26.6% infants and 28.2% children were receiving under dose that may lead to resistance not only among those who were prescribed under dose but also such bacteria become resistant and spread to other population to increase antimicrobial resistance. The irrational prescribing of antibiotics was found very high (above 50%) in Public sector hospital (Hospital-B) for every age group whereas in Private sector hospital (Hospital-A) this practice was found near to 50%. In this study the prescribing frequency of Amikacin, Cefixime, Cefotaxime, Meropenem, Amoxicillin, Vancomycin, Azithromycin, Levofloxacin and Clarithromycin was found above 80% in both hospitals (A and B). Among these, Amoxicillin, Penicillin, Erythromycin and Cephalexin showed higher resistance i.e. 49.2%.
本研究评估了巴基斯坦公立和私立医院12岁以下儿童抗生素不合理使用的处方模式。通过对住院患者床头病历(PBF)中抗菌药物使用模式的前瞻性临床评估以及培养敏感性试验(CST)报告来确定抗生素耐药性。记录了两个用于评估抗生素处方的指标:处方抗生素剂量(低剂量、合理剂量和高剂量)和用药指征(有效或无效)。通过培养敏感性试验确定了25种选定抗生素的耐药性。本研究表明,在私立医院,入住重症监护病房的77.7%的新生儿、13.3%的婴儿和9%的儿童正在接受抗生素治疗,其中只有57.3%的新生儿、62%的婴儿和59.9%的儿童用药指征有效,即因正确指征开具抗生素。27%的新生儿、19%的婴儿和22.1%的儿童抗生素处方剂量不足,这可能导致抗菌药物耐药性并增加住院费用。只有29.1%的新生儿、30%的婴儿和36.8%的儿童接受合理剂量用药。在公立医院,65.6%的新生儿、19.4%的婴儿和15%的儿童正在接受抗生素治疗。其中,35.3%的新生儿、35.6%的婴儿和39.8%的儿童用药指征有效。33.3%的新生儿、26.6%的婴儿和28.2%的儿童接受剂量不足的治疗,这不仅可能导致接受剂量不足治疗的患者产生耐药性,而且此类细菌会产生耐药性并传播到其他人群,从而增加抗菌药物耐药性。在公立医院(医院B),每个年龄组抗生素不合理处方率都非常高(超过50%),而在私立医院(医院A),这种情况接近50%。在本研究中,阿米卡星、头孢克肟、头孢噻肟、美罗培南、阿莫西林、万古霉素、阿奇霉素、左氧氟沙星和克拉霉素在两家医院(A和B)的处方频率均高于80%。其中,阿莫西林、青霉素、红霉素和头孢氨苄的耐药性较高,即49.2%。