a Specialist, Ankara University School of Medicine , Department of Chest Disease , Ankara , Turkey.
b Prof, Ankara University School of Medicine , Department of Chest Disease , Ankara , Turkey.
Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2018 Jan 2;14(1):111-117. doi: 10.1080/21645515.2017.1387703. Epub 2017 Nov 29.
Vaccination of healthcare personnel (HCP) is an effective measure for preventing the spread of influenza among at-risk patients. This study was conducted to determine influenza vaccination rates and activities among HCP working at a tertiary healthcare setting.
This study included 470 HCP (85 physicians, 134 nurses, 53 healthcare assistants, 44 paramedics, 47 medical secretaries, and 107 auxillary staff members) working at the emergency, cardiology, chest diseases, and internal medicine departments with the largest volume of patients with vaccination indication of two large university hospitals with similar medical practices and work environment. Each participant completed an anonymous questionnaire form.
A total of 470 HCP participated in the survey. The compliance rate of the HCP to participate in the survey was 93.6%. Of these, 26.7% had been vaccinated against influenza. Vaccination in the survey year was significantly associated with having regular influenza vaccinations (OR 48.66; 95% CI:[25.09-94.369]; P<.01); having an educational level of college or higher (OR 2.07; 95% CI:[1.03-4.15]; P<.05); being a physician (OR 4.25; 95% CI:[1.28-14.07]; P< .05); and a professional experience of more than 5 years (OR 2.02; 95%CI:[1.13-5.62]; P< .05). Physicians recommended and prescribed the influenza vaccine significantly more frequently than the pneumococcal vaccine (37.6% vs 30.6%, P = .03, 25.9% vs 17.6%, P = .001, respectively). Among all HCP, the reasons for vaccination included having the opinion that the vaccine provides a partial protection against the infection (75.2%), reduces work force loss (48.8%), reduces the rates of death and severe conditions like pneumonia (43.2%), and reduces hospitalization (40.8%). The HCP had been vaccinated to protect family members (81.6%), people around (51.2%), herself/himself (47.2%), and patients (28%) fom infection. The reasons of not getting vaccinated against influenza among HCP included fear of vaccine's adverse effects (31.0%), doubts about its efficacy (28.9%) and safety (22.3%), and lack of adequate knowledge about vaccination (16.2%).
Our results indicated that influenza vaccination rates are low in our whole HCP sample, with physicians having a slightly better rate than other HCP. Getting regularly vaccinated, having an educational level of college or higher, being a physician, and having a professional experience of more than 5 years positively affects the rate of future vaccinations. Physicians significantly more commonly recommended and prescribed the influenza vaccine than the pneumococcal vaccine. The most important reasons for getting vaccinated included having the opinion that the vaccine provided partial protection and intending to protect family members from infection. In our whole HCP sample, the reasons of not getting vaccinated against influenza included fear of vaccine's adverse effects and doubts about its efficacy and safety. Training meetings should be held for HCPs to underscore the importance of the influenza vaccine for protection of patients against the influenza.
为预防流感在高危患者中传播,对医护人员(HCPS)进行疫苗接种是一项有效措施。本研究旨在确定在具有类似医疗实践和工作环境的两家大型大学医院工作的三级医疗机构中,医护人员接种流感疫苗的情况和活动。
本研究纳入了在急诊、心脏病学、胸部疾病和内科部门工作的 470 名医护人员(85 名医生、134 名护士、53 名医疗助理、44 名护理人员、47 名医疗秘书和 107 名辅助人员)。每位参与者都填写了一份匿名问卷。
共有 470 名医护人员参与了调查。参与调查的医护人员的依从率为 93.6%。其中,26.7%的人接种了流感疫苗。在调查年度接种疫苗与定期接种流感疫苗显著相关(OR 48.66;95%CI:[25.09-94.369];P<.01);具有大学或以上学历(OR 2.07;95%CI:[1.03-4.15];P<.05);是医生(OR 4.25;95%CI:[1.28-14.07];P<.05);以及 5 年以上的专业经验(OR 2.02;95%CI:[1.13-5.62];P<.05)。医生推荐和开具流感疫苗的频率明显高于肺炎球菌疫苗(37.6%比 30.6%,P=.03;25.9%比 17.6%,P=.001)。在所有医护人员中,接种疫苗的原因包括认为疫苗对感染提供部分保护(75.2%)、减少劳动力损失(48.8%)、降低死亡和肺炎等严重疾病的发生率(43.2%)以及减少住院率(40.8%)。医护人员接种疫苗的原因包括保护家属(81.6%)、周围的人(51.2%)、自己(47.2%)和病人(28%)免受感染。医护人员未接种流感疫苗的原因包括担心疫苗的不良反应(31.0%)、对疫苗的疗效和安全性存疑(28.9%和 22.3%)以及缺乏足够的疫苗接种知识(16.2%)。
我们的研究结果表明,我们的医护人员总体接种流感疫苗的比例较低,医生的接种率略高于其他医护人员。定期接种疫苗、拥有大学或以上学历、作为医生和拥有 5 年以上专业经验,会积极影响未来的疫苗接种率。医生明显更常推荐和开具流感疫苗,而不是肺炎球菌疫苗。接种疫苗的最重要原因是认为疫苗提供了部分保护,以及希望保护家属免受感染。在我们的医护人员样本中,不接种流感疫苗的原因包括担心疫苗的不良反应和对疫苗的疗效和安全性存疑。应针对医护人员举行培训会议,强调流感疫苗对保护患者免受流感侵袭的重要性。