Huang S L, Chen L S, Zhang B, Liang L, Gong X X, Zhou Z G, Zhang S X, Luo X N, Lu Z M, Zhang S Y
Department of Otorhinolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, Guangdong General Hospital, Guangdong Academy of Medical Sciences, Guangzhou 510080, China.
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Nansha Hospital of Guangzhou First People's Hospital, Guangzhou 510515, China.
Zhonghua Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2017 Oct 7;52(10):744-748. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.1673-0860.2017.10.006.
To investigate the feasibility and significance of modified Killian(MK) method in the clinical diagnosis of congenital pyriform sinus fistula(CPSF) by electronic laryngoscopy. The following examinations were performed for 30 suspected cases of CPSF, including the traditional electronic laryngoscopy, MK examination(modified Killian position+ head rotation+ the Valsalva maneuver), barium swallow X-ray(BSX) and CT , and a prospective comparison among them were done. Patients were divided into two groups according to their age: young age group(≤14 years old) and older age group (>14 years old). The results of MK examination from the patients were analyzed and the positive diagnostic rates (PDR) between groups were compared by using χ(2) tests. Sinuses in 20 of 30 patients were depicted from pyriform sinus in BSX, and the PDR was 66.7%(20/30). The PRD of CT was 83.3%(25/30). The presence of air bubbles around the upper lobe of the thyroid gland or at the inferomedial edge of cricothyroid joints, morphological changes of thyroid grand as well as pseudo-fistula formation on lower neck were detected clearly on CT. Comparing to the traditional electronic laryngoscopy, the effect of exposing piriform fossa fistula by MK examination is significant(χ(2)=17.05, <0.05), with the PDR of 13.3%(4/30) and 76.7%(23/30) respectively. Nevertheless, comparing to BSX and CT, there were no statistically significant differences in the effect to diagnose CPSF (χ(2)=0.31, χ(2)=0.10 respectively, >0.05). The PDR of MK in older group is significantly higher than younger group(χ(2)=6.68, <0.05). MK examination can clearly reveal the hypopharyngeal anatomical structure and detect the sinus of CPSF .It could be a safe, feasible, convenient and economical method as an application in preoperative diagnosis and follow-up examination of clinical suspected CPSF.
探讨改良基利安(MK)法在电子喉镜下对先天性梨状窝瘘(CPSF)临床诊断的可行性及意义。对30例疑似CPSF患者进行了以下检查,包括传统电子喉镜检查、MK检查(改良基利安位+头部旋转+瓦尔萨尔瓦动作)、吞钡X线检查(BSX)和CT检查,并对它们进行前瞻性比较。根据年龄将患者分为两组:青年组(≤14岁)和老年组(>14岁)。分析患者MK检查结果,采用χ²检验比较组间阳性诊断率(PDR)。30例患者中,20例在BSX检查中显示梨状窝瘘,PDR为66.7%(20/30)。CT的PRD为83.3%(25/30)。CT清晰显示甲状腺上叶周围或环甲关节内下缘有气泡,甲状腺形态改变以及下颈部假性瘘管形成。与传统电子喉镜检查相比,MK检查暴露梨状窝瘘的效果显著(χ²=17.05,P<0.05),PDR分别为13.3%(4/30)和76.7%(23/30)。然而,与BSX和CT相比,诊断CPSF的效果无统计学差异(χ²分别为0.31、0.10,P>0.05)。老年组MK的PDR显著高于青年组(χ²=6.68,P<0.05)。MK检查能清晰显示下咽解剖结构并检测出CPSF的瘘管。作为临床疑似CPSF术前诊断及随访检查的应用方法,它可能是一种安全、可行、便捷且经济的方法。