Departments of Laboratory Medicine and Pathology, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Department of Pediatrics, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
J Mol Diagn. 2018 Jan;20(1):56-62. doi: 10.1016/j.jmoldx.2017.09.003. Epub 2017 Oct 19.
Stool is the diagnostic specimen of choice to identify enteropathogens in pediatric gastroenteritis. However, stool collection is challenging and its diagnostic characteristics in patients with isolated vomiting are unknown. Therefore, we evaluated if oral swabs are a suitable alternative specimen to stools. In total, 738 oral swabs and 577 stool specimens were collected from 738 children with vomiting and/or diarrhea. All specimens were tested by a laboratory-developed quantitative RT-PCR Gastroenteritis Virus Panel; 150 oral swabs and 577 stool specimens were tested by the commercial gastroenteritis pathogen panel. The Gastroenteritis Virus Panel identified adenovirus (n = 38), norovirus (n = 21), and rotavirus (n = 16) commonly in oral swabs. In stool specimens, rotavirus (n = 139), norovirus (n = 86), and adenovirus (n = 69) were detected commonly. Compared with stool specimens, the specificity of oral swabs was 99% (95% CI, 96%-100%); the sensitivity of oral swabs was 18% (95% CI, 14%-22%) for the detection of enteric viruses. The Gastrointestinal Pathogen Panel identified enteric bacteria and parasites in stool but not in oral swabs. Given the lower sensitivity of oral swabs, stool remains a preferable specimen to detect enteric viruses. However, with their high specificity, oral swabs can be considered as a suitable specimen if stool specimens are unavailable. Nevertheless, negative oral swabs require a confirmative test of stool specimens.
粪便是诊断儿童肠胃炎病原体的首选标本。然而,粪便采集具有挑战性,且其在单纯呕吐患者中的诊断特征尚不明确。因此,我们评估了口腔拭子是否是粪便的合适替代标本。共采集了 738 例呕吐和/或腹泻患儿的 738 份口腔拭子和 577 份粪便标本。所有标本均采用实验室开发的定量 RT-PCR 肠炎病毒检测试剂盒进行检测;150 份口腔拭子和 577 份粪便标本采用商业肠炎病原体检测试剂盒进行检测。肠炎病毒检测试剂盒在口腔拭子中常见检测到腺病毒(n=38)、诺如病毒(n=21)和轮状病毒(n=16)。在粪便标本中,常见检测到轮状病毒(n=139)、诺如病毒(n=86)和腺病毒(n=69)。与粪便标本相比,口腔拭子的特异性为 99%(95%可信区间,96%-100%);口腔拭子检测肠道病毒的敏感性为 18%(95%可信区间,14%-22%)。胃肠道病原体检测试剂盒在粪便中可检测到肠道细菌和寄生虫,但在口腔拭子中不可检测到。由于口腔拭子的敏感性较低,因此粪便仍然是检测肠道病毒的首选标本。然而,鉴于口腔拭子的高特异性,如果无法获得粪便标本,也可将其视为合适的标本。但是,阴性的口腔拭子仍需要粪便标本的确认性检测。