Studeny Jane, Weber Elyssa, Kavanaugh Brian C, Dupont-Frechette Jennifer A, Tellock Perrin P, Maher Isolde D, Haisley Lauren D, McCurdy Kyle, Holler Karen A
a Department of Clinical Psychology , Antioch University , Keene , New Hampshire , USA.
b Department of Psychology , University of Massachusetts Boston , Boston , Massachusetts , USA.
Appl Neuropsychol Child. 2019 Jan-Mar;8(1):40-49. doi: 10.1080/21622965.2017.1381098. Epub 2017 Oct 23.
This study examined the role of executive functioning in constructional task performance (measured with the Rey Complex Figure Test-Copy Condition [RCFT] and Beery-Buktenica Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration [Beery-VMI]) within a children's psychiatric inpatient setting. A chart review was conducted for 88 children (aged 6-12) who received a neuropsychological evaluation during a psychiatric inpatient hospitalization. Multiple regression analyses investigated the role of executive and nonexecutive demands on RCFT and Beery-VMI performance. Forty-three percent of the sample displayed a constructional weakness. Children with a constructional weakness had lower FSIQ scores and a higher rate of executive dysfunction. Performance on the RCFT was independently predicted by perceptual ability (i.e., Matrix Reasoning; p = .008; β = .340) and attention/executive dysfunction (p = .003; β = -.342; 9.4% of variance), while performance on the Beery-VMI was independently predicted by constructional ability (i.e., Block Design; p = .004, β = .338). Results of this study demonstrate that the RCFT has greater executive demand than the VMI and yields a greater rate of impaired performance in an inpatient child sample as compared to the VMI. Clinical and research practices should consider the distinct differences between various constructional measures to ensure their proper use and interpretation with consideration to their varying executive and nonexecutive demands.
本研究在儿童精神科住院环境中,考察了执行功能在建构任务表现(通过雷氏复杂图形测验-临摹条件[RCFT]和贝里-布克滕尼卡视觉-运动整合发育测验[贝里-VMI]进行测量)中的作用。对88名儿童(6至12岁)进行了图表回顾,这些儿童在精神科住院期间接受了神经心理学评估。多元回归分析研究了执行和非执行需求对RCFT和贝里-VMI表现的作用。43%的样本表现出建构能力缺陷。存在建构能力缺陷的儿童FSIQ得分较低,执行功能障碍发生率较高。RCFT的表现由感知能力(即矩阵推理;p = 0.008;β = 0.340)和注意力/执行功能障碍(p = 0.003;β = -0.342;方差的9.4%)独立预测,而贝里-VMI的表现由建构能力(即积木设计;p = 0.004,β = 0.338)独立预测。本研究结果表明,与VMI相比,RCFT对执行功能的要求更高,在住院儿童样本中表现受损的发生率也更高。临床和研究实践应考虑各种建构测量方法之间的明显差异,以确保根据其不同的执行和非执行需求正确使用和解释这些方法。